Family owned and operated, Magic Fountain specializes in delicious homemade ice cream made fresh from local ingredients.
9825 Main Road (Factory Ave.) Mattituck , NY 11952 United States
| Outdoor Seating | Yes |
One of the best ice cream shops on Long Island . Salted Caramel is superb.
Amazing weekly special flavors. This week: fig and honey , sweet corn and coconut avocado .
Ali is one of the sweetest people- to match his icecream , the favours here are amazing! exotic seasonals like peppermint , eggnog , kulfi , cocoachili guiness , and more, Im a local and I love it!
Friendly staff and delicious ice cream . Whenever I come back into the area, I’ll definitely be visiting again.
Probably one of the best ice cream places I've ever been to. Caramel Apple and Kulfi are the prize.
Blackberry is great. Everything is great. Awesome ice cream , ice cream cakes , service.
Best ice cream ! Always new flavors and big scoops! Birthday cake is a fav
Great little shop that isn't too far out on the North Fork . Big variety of ice cream -- try the pumpkin
DELICIOUSLY scooped ice cream . You have to try a cone of the rainbow cookie .
Ice cream is delicious... when it’s not crawling in cockroaches. On 2 separate occasions I got greeted by a roach when grabbing a spoon and napkin. They can work on overall establishment cleanliness
Smores ice cream is deeeeelicious
rocky road , oreo and honey cinnamon are must haves. super creamy and full of flavor.
Delicious ice cream ! And a lot of fun flavors. The goat cheese tastes like cheesecake
Good mix of classic and interesting flavors. Kids working here are very patient with samples....
Very good. Only problem...the "no sugar added" is also fat free. Ih well . Still delicious.
Single scoop of cherry vanilla in a waffle cone , every time
Seriously great ice cream and fun spot, get the cookies and cream
If it's your first time, you have to try the soft serve . It's much better than Carvel.
Rainbow cookie ice cream
Best ice cream on the North Fork .
S'mores and salted caramel ice cream are great picks
Everything
All tasty options but s’mores was my favorite.
The malt mania ice cream was a let down and I forgot that waffles cones are gluten intensive so double fail. Most of the stuff they make us delicious though.
Mocha Chocolate Chip . Yum!
Incredible! Try the avocado-coconut!
Mocha-Chip and Butter Pecan ... wOw !! My favorite NoFo ice cream stop!!
There lavender ice cream is fantastic
Try having one scoop of red velvet and one of chocolate chili ! So good together!
Amazing seasonal ice cream flavors . Just after St. Pstty's day and there is Guinness , Irish Cream, Kulfi , mud pie , and many more.
Peach Melba. Perfect to cool off on the perfect sunny day.
ChocoChili opens up your sinuses. Great Flavor!
English Butter Toffee , and Rum Raisin - utterly sublime!! Nice service, :-)
You haven't lived life unless you tried the Cookie Monster flavor. End of story.
Try the ice cream !
My favorite ice cream shop
Try the butter pecan
Great ice cream
The cake batter ice cream tho! 🙌🏻
Salted caramel flavor ftw.
Great place tots hitting it again :)))
Who makes a better cookies n cream ? Nobody.
Fig & dates...unbelievably creamy, I feel like a kid!!
Irish cream is the best!
Wait outside. Let the kids go inside.
Honey cinnamon !!!
pumpkin rocks. kulfi if u like spice
Try the Chocolate-Chili!
Chocolate soft serve. They have spumoni Italian ice! - Margarita Krup
Best ice cream shop hands down. Quaint cozy and clean. - Paul Inzerillo
There are a lot of stores between all three sections. You could find just about anything. Everything from clothing and jewelry to cookware and office supplies. You need to shop here at least once. - Michele Dowling
Pies are fantastic! If there's a line, don't worry because it moves fast - Cynthia Lin
Beautiful for a sunset walk along the inlet. - Dan Spinosa