Gray Brothers Cafeteria

one of my favorite restaurants ! I love their pie , especially the chocolate and banana ! Baked Tilapia is amazing! My kids love their fried chicken and chicken tenders ????

Gray Brothers is the place to go for colossal comfort food in the Indianapolis area, from mountainous mac & cheese to mouth-watering meat loaf and delicious pies . As seen on Man v Food.

fried chicken is amazing here. love that the line starts with pie/dessert before the mains and sides. TIP: free refills so just get a small drink

Country fried steak is my favorite! Their menu changes daily so you never know what they'll be serving, but the food is always delicious.

Sooooo good. Everything taste wonderful. Great prices. Can't wait to move on this side of town to be able to eat here more!

Excellent fried chicken and roast beef here! This place is good for a quick stop or grabbing something to go.

It's rare to find people that do, but if you like fried chicken livers like I do, then this is a place you're going to want to be sure and get some.

Everything here is great!! The food is amazing and the staff is so friendly ! 10/10!

Chicken livers were great. Pie is amazing

Possibly best old-school cafeteria in Indiana

Love this place. Their mash potatoes are the best and you must get the banana cream pie !

Good food chicken lives fried potatoes macaroni and apricot pie .

The delicious hysteria of having to choose among so much good-looking food is a state of mind known to cognoscenti as cafeteria anxiety. Read more

Love the chocolate pie , really anything they have I would recommend . It is al good!!!!!!!!!!

The baked fish and their pies are just amazing! Love their food!

It was its usual great -- would have been better if they had their chicken livers , which my wife loves.

Great portions, well worth the price and service

Nice place to eat and visit . Delicious food.

Great food with friendly service .

Grays is one of my top 10 places to eat of all time. It is simply the best

Baked Tilapia and don't forget to grab a piece of Coconut Cream Pie !

Can't beat the roast beef , mashed potatoes , Mac & cheese - their green beans are my favorite.

Best fried chicken in Indiana and chocolate pie to die for

Everything

They have a large building which is accessible from all sides, plus they have ample parking .

I can never choose between the butterscotch and chocolate pie .

Try the Chocolate Cake - Best chocolate cake I've had in awhile.

Good but I prefer Shapiros in Indy downtown. Of course they were out if the famous strawberry pie

Everything is great!

Try the baked tilapia , it's really good.

Best chicken livers you've ever had.

Pie and livers haha

If you are even REMOTELY close, GO. You will not regret it.

Find them on twitter to get the menu for the day! @graybrotherscafe

The chicken (beef ) and noodles is the best!

The chicken noodles are the best

Check out Gray Brothers Cafeteria as seen on Man vs Food Read more

The fried chicken is divine.

Love the beets and strawberry pie ! So yummy!

Have the meatloaf . No joke. Wow this place is worth the drive.

Delicious. #burp

Felt like I just had Thanksgiving and Christmas meals packed in together!

Please eat the pork tenderloin and the carrot cake . Amazing.

The line is long but the food is worth the wait!!!!! :)

Fried chicken or beef Manhattan

If you like eating at the nursing home , you'll love it here!!

The chocolate pie is one of the best things in earth.

They finally have blueberry pie !!! Best pie ever.

Fried chicken

Best MAC & cheese and chocolate pie