McAlisters Deli

McAlister's Deli offers a menu packed with delicious sandwiches, spuds, salads, soups and sweets — plus our world-famous tea.

8 / 10
159
ratings
  • Phone

    (317) 872-6500

  • Website

    indymcalisters.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    mcalistersin

  • Facebook

    196577057034094

  • Type

    Deli

Address

8840 Michigan Rd Ste 104 (at Vincennes Rd.) Indianapolis , IN 46268 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dessert

Comments / 53


Keywords:

tea mcallister tortilla soup iced tea cookies good for a quick meal spicy food chef salad gluten-free food sandwiches vegetarian food casual chicken lunch potatoes turkey Heath bar cranberries quick service clean
Chris R

One of the best McAllister 's Delis I've been to. The atmosphere and the excellent service staff really made the difference on my last visit. Food made to order and at the right temp. Sweet tea !

Eleete Frostpaw

Staff not nearly as friendly and happy as other locations. Sweet tea is always a saver though. I've had a big problem with never being able to leave here full regardless of what I order.

Sean Molin

Their spuds are actually two whole baked potatoes put together. Get "half" and add a cup of soup or half a sandwich if you like variety. I get tired of that giant potato after half.

G Miller

The staff has always been helpful and quite friendly . We visit often enough that most of them seem to remember us and seem happy to see us again.

Melissa B

Great place for lunch . The food is consistently good, and the menu is plentiful. Order unsweet tea and add two Splenda packets for "sweet tea taste" with no calories.

Kyle Fogg

I'm not a soup and salad guys, but the 1/2 chef salad and 1/2 tortilla soup is awesome. The tortilla soup is spicy !

Keith Olmstead

Great quick service and good food along with fantastic ice tea .

Stephanie Henry

Delicious food. One of my favorite places to get lunch

Paul Thomas

Love the Pick Two, let's you pick your two favorite items for one low price $6.79

Aubrey Phillips

Fantastic tortilla soup . Great to pair with the Reuben !

Kristi Krass

The chicken tortilla soup is addicting. I also love that they give huge water glasses vs. the teeny water cups most restaurants use.

G Miller

Not sure what kind of soup you want? Ask for a sample, and they'll give you a small cup to taste each choice before you purchase.

Heather Sanders

Spicy Southwest Chicken Griller is awesome!

Lauren K

Melly is the best, friendliest server! She should get a raise :)

Sean Molin

It's almost as if every time you come they've raised prices across the board.

Andrea H

The new Secret menu is out. Old favs brought back for a limited time.

Someone P

The Big Nasty is to die for!!!! :-D Ppl who work here are always nice too!

Say it in Shirts

Bring the kids on Mondays! Kids 12 and under eat free w/the purchase of an adult meal.

Arcy

Coffee is only $0.89 for 16 oz cup (to go) or free refills and free WiFi in restaurant

Someone P

Edward at register is so kind. I love their Big Nasty. Delish. 

Scott Keath

Ask for Scott. He's awesome! Best....employee...ever!

Scott Bauer

If you are part of a group you need to order together (you can pay separate). it makes them mad if you don't.

Scentsy Super Star Director Wicklessmolly

Great food and awesome staff !

Chris Brown

I hear if you bought iced tea and brought your own food, that would be a dick move.

Sherry

Peach tea & McAllister 's club = perfection

Christopher Mabbitt

Sweet Tea and spud max, best combo ever!

Alex

The managers are banging everyone up in here! Beware of the booths .......... Foods fine

Marco Antonio Hopf

Sandwich Carrot cake

Johnny Plookeeplonkers

There's this hot chick named Melissa B that eats there - if only I could get up the nerve to talk to her...

JB Buckner

Lunch crowd = seat stalking. Get here early or leave disappointed.

Joe Watson

New blacked chicken sandwich the bomb!

Jim Holzmeyer

best chocolate chip cookies anywhere

Patrick Swickheimer

Muffaletta was good☺

Ted Givens

Orange Cranberry Club and a Heath bar cookie yum yum

Paul Lucas

The food at this location is as good as any McAlister's, but the staff is not nearly as nice. They're not rude, per se, just not as warm or friendly as I've come to expect from the McAlister's chain.

Angela Miller

Pick two is great!!!!

Jonathan Winn

Waited 20 minutes to find out they lost our order with no evidence of the transaction. Also out of spuds !! Tea is still delicious.

Dashuna Wilson

Had great service

Dan Barnett

I hear you can just order iced tea and bring your own food

Sarah Burnette

Was crazy busy yesterday... barely found a table. Good food.

Andrea H

Love the Roasted Corn soup !

Taylor Monaco

Try the tortilla soup , its' amazing!

Haleigh Castino

Taco Salad !

Anthony Barnett

I'm lovin the music !

Angela Miller

FREE TEA DAY!!!!

Taylor Monaco

The Basil Parmesan Chicken is top notch.

Alex Neil

Beware some of the booths ...insider.

Joseph Dixon

Super slow service! My order got lost Before that they forgot our pickles with the sandwiches . Sweet tea at MsDonalds is better

Mallorie L

Agree about the staff , not very professional in front of customers. Awkward

neon penguin

They need a sign to put on the table stand that says "No, I don't want a refill."

Similar places nearby :

7.5
Deli
DiBella's

Awesome subs! High quality meats and bread. The Dagwood on the everything roll all the way!! - ᴡ Wilen

9.0
Deli
Fat Dan's Deli

Its all good! The brisket is delicious and try the Durty Tots. - CS_just_CS

7.9
Deli
Midday Gourmet Deli

First time here. Great deals, tasty food, and awesome personalities. - Janeé B

8.9
Warehouse or Wholesale Store
Costco

Nice variety of products at volume prices. MJ and I enjoyed sampling fresh baked Parmesan Garlic and Multigrain breads. Purchased and bringing (4) loafs home - David Bowling

8.3
Big Box Store
Target

Cute affordable clothing and shoes. Love when they do a designer line! - Adrienne Johnson

4.9
Big Box Store
Walmart Supercenter

Very busy store, they run out if items quickly - Jenny Bookwalter