Shortstop Deli

Shortstop Deli is a sandwich spot Ithaca located in United States.

9 / 10
117
ratings
  • Phone

    (607) 273-1030

  • Website

    shortstopdeli.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Sandwich Spot

Address

200 W Seneca St Ithaca , NY 14850 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 36


Keywords:

sandwiches hot truck miracle whip good for a quick meal good for a late night casual great value authentic ice cream pickles turkey bacon bread inexpensive meats parking dill tomatoes peppers brown mustard
Dave Kornreich

Great for a quick meal . Good sandwiches made from pretty much any meat you might want, or get a famous Hot Truck Pizza Sub ! Mmmmm! There's no room to sit, really: be ready to take it with you.

Tyler Wilson

So many darn types of coffee , it's like coffee heaven, also ipen 24 hours is a major plus, especially after working late hours. Good sub spot for on the go

Chris Thurber

I always get a BBQ chicken with bacon and Swiss. It's really the freshness and quality of the food that makes it so delicious. Ordinary sandwiches with extraordinary quality.

Brad L

Build-your-own sandwiches are great. Toast the bread and get the meat hot for maximum tastiness.

Zach Montague

Best deli in the region. Also maybe the only genuine deli in the region. Always open.

Sam Molter

Get the Italian meat on French bread and def. get it toasted (it’s what the place is known for).

Phil Adams

Literally everything on the menu is amazing. If you can't choose you want a double Sui.

Brad Treat

My favorite sandwich : Corned beef with swiss cheese on French bread , hot and toasted. Topped with cole slaw , tomatoes , cucumbers , russian dressing , and pepper .

Melissa K

After years of getting subs , I discovered their toasted ciabatta and I've never looked back! :)

Michael Marranzini

Making your own frankenstein Sammy! Its all good.

Andrew Weiser

Always get your sub toasted! Expert tip: Shortstop is open 24-hours. Get your late-night grub on!

Micah M

One of the best sandwich shops in the area!

Jeff A

Double RBI with brown mustard and horse, swiss, lettuce, tomato , sweet and hot peppers , dill and sweet pickles .

Doug Ray

This place will really fill you up with a grand slam. Proceed with ambition

Amy Gaines

Great sandwiches and very affordable

Paige Klingerman

Easily top 5 favorite breakfast sandwich I've ever had

Sijan Khan

Love their sandwiches . Open 24hr/7day

Aisha Freelove

Custom made subs and they are delicious

Royale Just

The all night spot too grub. That's the shit i love

Chris Crooker

Hot Truck sandwiches - awesome!

Chris Thurber

5am-10am: $2 off!

Drew Mickey

A bit pricey but well worth it

brp

Love the turkey , American, cucumber , dill pickle , miracle whip and black pepper sandwich .

Ayana Richardson

All breakfast sandwiches are $2 off between 5-10!

Adam Berlinsky-Schine

PMP or WGC

Craig J.

Great place to grab a snack before going Finger Lakes wine tasting .

Noah Davis

Ciabatta on fleek!

Alison J.

Get an MVP card, buy 7 get 1 free, drinks & eats

Barrett Lane

My favorite sandwich : Turkey , swiss, bacon , lettuce, tomato onion on ciabatta with Miracle Whip .

L. K.

Poor Man's Pizza gets two thumbs up!

Desiree Remson

Awesome ice cream

S-Woodrow Chichester

Cheapest breakfast sandwiches in town .

Ted Trembinski

When The Hot Truck is closed, Short Stop is the only thing that hits the spot.

Matthew Kinnick

Great hot subs ! Open 24 hours !

Mark Fong

Bring back the Firm! Pls? :-)

jim Bouderau

Go bacon or go home

Similar places nearby :

8.6
Sandwich Spot
Gorgers

The Caribbean fire sub is incredible. The scotch bonnet citrus mustard is delicious and hot if that's you're thing. And the bonnets are homegrown! So good - Christopher Miranda

6.3
Sandwich Spot
Firehouse Subs

Turkey bacon ranch. Yummy - Tammy C-Val

6.0
Sandwich Spot
Jimmy John's

Awesome subs, delicious rolls. Turkey Tom (#4) for the win! Sprouts! - Steve Poland

8.5
Ice Cream
Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop

The creamiest Ice cream ever. I had the honeycomb which was just great! - Pilgrim ????

8.8
Park
Stewart Park

Beautiful view. Great park. Peaceful. Good for walking. BBQs. Family, or just to hang outdoors. And nice view of Lake Cayuga also!???? - Tyler Wilson

8.9
Ice Cream
Purity Ice Cream

Incredibly creamy ice cream - definitely worth the stop. Have some interesting old-school flavors & offerings. Delicious! - Steve B