Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Dine Buffet, Family Style or Menu style on Amish-Style favorites like fried chicken, real mashed potatoes, Amish noodles and over 20 varieties of pie!

9 / 10
125
ratings
  • Phone

    (260) 768-4725

  • Website

    thebluegate.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    bluegatein

  • Facebook

    151783358209520

  • Type

    American Restaurant

Address

195 N Van Buren St Shipshewana , IN 46565 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert

Comments / 35


Keywords:

great amish style buffet style food breakfast food desserts pies good for working casual mashed potatoes restaurants dinner brunch food friendly staff lunch well rhubarb apples peanut butter family style sampler platter
Phyllis Box

Had dinner buffet which is downstairs. $16./ea drink xtra, over priced. Fried chicken good. Fairly clean , good service . Gift shop & shows upstairs daily, horse/buggy rides outside for $10 or $20.

T-town Tom

A buffet of home style food that still tastes like home style food is tough to pull off, but they do a great job. Plus, a bakery/gift shop to take good stuff home with you.

Bekah Houff

The meatloaf is fabulous! Get it with a side of mashed potatoes and green beans . Mmmm.

Dan Lam

Great Amish style food here. Be sure to take home some Amish peanut butter and try the apple butter as well .

Erin Brodhagen

The Country Roast Beef was excellient! Would go back just for that alone :-)

Marcia Voss

Salad bar was wonderful! So fresh and lots to chose from!

Jean Helm

Ate at the buffet downstairs. Salad bar was nice. Entrees were delicious

Anthony Gettig

This place is a gem. A little pricey but well worth it. Very friendly staff .

Randy Tate

Great Amish style fare. Everything is great!

Shawna Bates

The breakfast buffet is wonderful! About $10 a person.

Greg Dominick

Gotta have the fried chicken AND a slice of butterscotch pie . Nothing better!

Lynn Spino

Make sure you bring your appetite! Great bakery in there!

Joe Baumgartner

Amazing home-cooked food. You will not be disappointed.

Zephanie Reed

Don't get the lemon meringue . You don't think you'll regret it... But you will. Trust me.

Sue Holecheck

My favorite place to get rhubarb cream pie !

Kelly C

The fried chicken is amazing!!

Rose Tyler

Friendly staff and great food

Tim Budoff

Breakfast buffet style was awesome!

Cheryl Glowacki

Awesome place!! Great food

Richard Parrack

lots to see and do in this little town !

Theresa Lucas

Food was fabulous and people were extremely friendly ...

Kelly Yap

Make sure you save room for pie !

Kim Corney

Family style very good!

Kristi Dane

Amish PB is the best!;)

Amanda Berkey

Nursing mothers room is available in the restroom with comfy chairs .

Mark Moore

Wonderful Food and Hospitality

Kristen Carline

Everything is delicious!

Kerri Hicks-Arredondo

Breakfast was great!

Laura Hecker

BAKED GOODS

Sandy Piehl

Food just OK, very heavy, onion rings thick & to much breading .

Ron Leix

The Amish Sample Platter is excellent!

Paul Chambers

Excellent meatloaf !

Angela

Generous servings of super yummy down-home cooking'!

Benji Buddy

OMG! food is great!

Carrie Callaway-Dennison

Fish Fry Friday!!!!

Similar places nearby :

7.4
American
Auction Restaurant

Really great atmosphere. Staff is polite and the food is great - Ericka Lane

6.8
Coffee Shop
Wana Cup Cafe

Try the fried mush! Good coffee too! - Jim Gillette

7.2
Boutique
Davis Mercantile

There are so many cute shops. A carousel is on the top floor and there is an amazing pretzel place as well ???? - Rose Tyler

8.1
Department Store
Yoder Department Store

Very nice folks here. They go above and beyond to be of service to everyone. - Paul

7.7
Flea Market
Shipshewana Flea Market

Worth a visit, mostly imports in vendor spaces, some wood crafts, home decor, kites, $1. Store items, baked pretzels, kettle corn, Amish baked goods, plants etc. - Phyllis Box