Tellers: An American Chophouse
NYTimes - "Possibly the best steak I've ever eaten" One of the most strikingly beautiful dining rooms on the Island Come see what the talk is about!
605 Main St Islip , NY 11751 United States
| Credit Cards | Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard) |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
| Menus | Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour |
| Drinks | Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails |
Comments / 27
Keywords:
Try the shrimp & lobster wonton , It's amazingly lite & not greasy. You can really taste them both. The hoy sing sauce adds a nice touch. You get a nice portion (6) as well .
Phenomenal, will return. Had the 16oz wagyu , cooked perfectly. Everything was outstanding, duck fat fries , lobster Mac , clams . Can’t wait to go back.
I had the surf and turf and it was sublime. Lucky for me I came on their 15th anniversary and they had unlimited wine pairing with their plates.
Great food and service. Get the 40 oz rib-eye, asparagus , mushrooms and tater tots .
Go on a Tuesday night for a $50, 3 course dinner with Wine Pairings ! Or go on a Sunday for a Prix-fix 3 course meal
Apps - great, $54 Filet was dry and grey when I ordered it medium. Bourbon $68 steak dry and not worth it! Wines were nice. Scalloped potatoes not great. Whipped potatoes & spinach were great!
Bring the bigger wallet. Well worth it. Special occasions birthdays romantic dinners for two.
Price fix for restaurant week was great! Filet mignon Wellington was awese!
Get the Delmonico Rib Eye with the Truffle Sauce ... To die for!!!
The lobster bisque and half chicken are very good
Excellent service . Oysters were small bit good. A fine room to enjoy a good steak .
Food is all good#expensive "gin da loon" hang out on weekends!
Duck fat French fries and beef Wellington so amazing
Probably the best steak in Suffolk county !
The Salmon and "5 Cheese Mac" are sublime ????
We reviewed Tellers Chophouse, and our critic loved the Signature Ribeye . Read more
oysters ????
The most delicious steak tips with mashed potatoes umm order @ the bar ! Awesome!
Tuesday Night Wine Dinner is spectacular + easy on the wallet.
Glass of malbec and steak salad = great lunch
Giant tater tots & ny strip
Great south bay brew- delightful!
Get the Filet mignon Wellington !!! It's delish.
Zagat rated & vallet parking . What a great combination!!!
Tellers Steak House
Sammy Hagar might be in the house.
No more half price sushi at the bar on weekdays. In fact, no more sushi at all :(
Similar places nearby :
We went for our Rehearsal Dinner and they were accommodating, friendly and extremely attentive. The food was well prepared and served in a timely manner. - Lloyd G
Awesome Food, Fantastic People and Great Atmosphere - Sharon McDonough
Place United States » New York » Suffolk County » Islip