Ruschmeyer's

Ruschmeyer's is part of the Chelsea Hotels. Chelsea Hotels believes the best hotels are places where guests feel free to be themselves and do their own thing. As such, we are creating environments at our hotel in Montauk that are conducive to individuality, authenticity, creativity, and community...

7 / 10
249
ratings
Address

161 Second House Rd Montauk , NY 11954 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi Free
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Dinner
Drinks Cocktails

Comments / 49


Keywords:

lanterns dancing cute good service trendy desserts casual bar breakfast food corn watermelon jalapeños dinner buratta bingo swordfish summer camp radishes cabins lines
Nikki Bogopolskaya

Oh, just my favorite bar in Montauk. Go for dinner and sit outside to avoid the hour-long line that builds up right around 10pm on summer weekends. Group prefixe is pricey but worth the convenience!

The Corcoran Group

This fun summer camp themed hotel , restaurant and bar is popular among summer visitors. Chow down on a lobster roll paired with a spicy watermelon cocktail , and then dance the night away.

Jillian

Such a fun, campy vibe for relaxed Hamptons nights. Bar scene is young and fun, too! Everything we had was amazing: Cocktails , lobster buratta , clam pizza , spaghettini , and ALL the desserts .

christian svanes kolding

four seasons prices with motel six amenities . young staff does best it can with limited mandate. grounds upon which the cabins sit are lovely but furnishings far from bohemian chic , just ikea-cheap.

Heather Fink

Loved the clam pizza , tuna app, spicy watermelon drink, watermelon beer . The chicken salad looked amazing. Great looking spot, lots of hot people, beautiful chill vibe plus pretty lanterns .

Jenna Drapkin

if you like peace and quiet i recommend a weekday night stay here. super chill and really cool hotel .

Jorge Urrutia

The watermelon jalapeño drink is interesting. Try the lobster roll and the soft shell crab po'boy... And the pasta with scallops and ginger

Manda Shettleton

Sit outdoors. Big old trees are adorned with lanterns . Feels like the middle of nowhere. It's magical! Busy but not annoying busy like surf lodge . Had a few nightcaps!

Jeremy Beck

Beautiful place with a great layout across from the lake . The food was pretty good, but overpriced for the portions, and the specials on the board were 2 weeks old. I prefer it for the bar scene.

Gilt City

After a dinner at Ruschmeyer’s, you'll likely want to book an overnight trip. Truly an activity-based resort , guests take up kite boarding, paddle boarding, yoga , and ping pong .

Travel + Leisure

A summer camp for grown-ups in Montauk. Think cabins clustered around a decorative tepee, bingo nights, Ping-Pong, and a bar in an oversize sandbox.

Andrea Barrezueta

The food here keeps getting better and better. By far one of the best meals in Montauk this year.

Justin Ferranti

Get there before 10pm or be willing to wait 1h+ in line

dara lynne

Super crowded . Don't bother going for dinner without a reservation and even then be prepared to be stuffed into a huge crowd. Get the pesto pasta -- delicious.

BluePrint

Fantastic vibe both inside and out. The fresh watermelon jalapeno special cocktail this past weekend was out of control delicious!

Andrea Barrezueta

Food was actually delicious.. Mussels , swordfish and striped bass were amazing... Service, that's another question

offManhattan .com

Come for the cute surfers and corn succotash topped with peekytoe crab . The Elderflower lemonade cocktail is like drinking a glass of summer. oM approved.

Mario Jr Haddad

Had an overspiced seafood boil. Lobster was perfectly cooked though and service was subtle.

Anna Frenkel

Grab a bottle of rosé and chug it on the dance floor while dancing to 80s music . It's okay girl -- this is what your 20s are for.

Chris Marotta

Great lobster roll . Beware of the crowd on a weekend night...it's a sea of pink and mint .

Carolyna Z

It's like an adult camp, so fun, food is delicious, always a good crowd!

Carlotta deV

The Monkfish Green Curry is fabulous. Also, do not leave without trying the spicy watermelon cocktail !!!

Meg Farmer

Lots of space, outdoor fire pits are a nice touch.

Claire

Always a good place if you're in the mood for a dance party ????

Amanda Jabes

Have you played giant jenha yet? Or perhaps just ended up at B-list sand bar with the fire pits ?

Kevin Roche

There's no bathroom accessible from the dance floor , if you go you'll need to wait in line to get back in.

lexi peters

Grab a drink at the bar and sit out on the picnic blankets out back. Best.

Mike Kallmeyer

Made a reservation 3 months in advance only to have it denied at the last minute and get cussed out by the manager. Really cool courtyard but it is always a chaotic shitshow. Not worth the hassle.

Helly K

Drink - moscato crush; dessert - banana cream pie is amazing. Food is decent, but not spectacular.

Charlie Blackburn

If you get shooed to the right you end up in the donkey sandpit. You just might be a donkey yourself.

Aubrey Sabala

Get the Ruschmeyer. Hold the agave . (You're welcome.)

Ellie Rountree

Gorgeous courtyard . Grab a drink and sit outside under the Chinese lanterns .

Alyssa

get the pim's cup. they'll make it in a single serving too (not just a pitcher ). yum!

Andrea Dulko

Solid free breakfast .

Ling Luke

loved the radishes with olive oil , order the burger

Mélanie Vecchio

Spacious , nice setting

Heather W

LOVE the jalapeño margarita ! A must try. Great environment

Carly B

Teepee of trust: share a secret with strangers in the teepee.

Eric

Very cool. Get your fix before it becomes too crowded . Music painfully loud though.

Andrew S

Best bar in the Hamptons

Denise Quaglia

The clam pizza is probably the best thing on the menu, must try

Jackie R

#spoileralert...secret bathroom outside before bunk...(errrr cabin ) one

Maridi Nalle

Food is meh. Service is without mentorship. Super cute grounds, restaurant , and outdoor bar tho.

Marianne Hamilton

Definitely order the lobster roll !

Elena V.

Service very slow and inconsistent! A lot of riff-raff here at night!

Jan Gardner

Food so so, speciality drinks $16.00, not worth the trip. Atmosphere nice.

Jasmine D

Gross food, even more overpriced than most places in the Hamptons.

Tonia Ries

Good Vodka Gimlets

Donna Yee

RUDE female bartenders . Sorry I don't buy you drinks.

Similar places nearby :

7.0
Restaurant
Ruschmeyer's Restaurant

great place to spend a night with friends - Erin Shea

7.4
Hotel
The Surf Lodge

Lobster roll is pricy at $27 but so worth it. Get the Endless Summer cocktail! - Nicole S

8.9
Hotel
Crow's Nest

Check out the outdoor bar by the water for drinks and light bites. Love for sunsets. - Carli D

8.7
Hotel
Gurney's Montauk Resort and Seawater Spa

Loved our two night getaway from NYC. Rooms have been updated. Right ON the beach. Great spa. They were booked out for the last night so stayed at Montauk Manor...Oh, how the mighty FELL! - Rupert Noffs

7.3
Bar
The Point Bar & Grill

The food is moderately priced and SO so good. (Steak sandwich and the seared tuna are great!) And I agree with Camilla - keep the chocolate volcano for yourself! Amazing! - Warszawa

8.2
Bar
Stephen Talkhouse

It’s the best place in the Hamptons for a good time listening to cool music while enjoying the local scene, dancing or just chilling with a cold drink. - Hotel Indigo

7.3
Hotel
Sole East Resort

Mussels and frites were amazing. Best dish vs ceviche and tuna tartar. By far. - Andrea Barrezueta