Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East

A Madison pizza treasure serving 23 years of unique, award winning pies with renowned salads, subs, homemade lasagna, pasta and more. Offering contact free delivery, carryout, and catering on Madison's east side. The Atwood neighborhood is where it all began!...

9 / 10
116
ratings
Address

2916 Atwood Ave (at S Fair Oaks Ave) Madison , WI 53704 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 23


Keywords:

pizza nickel nuggets fetalicious cheese curds good for groups casual good for dates salads bar brunch food alcohol dinner lunch
Ally M

Their unique pizza topping combinations are so delicious - don't be afraid to try something crazy!

Yoli Z

Fetalicious FTW. I promise you won't need any additional spices.

Tara Van Rose

I eat the Spinach cheese bread with vegan cheese like once a week. Ask for vegan marinara too.

Paul Lane

The vegetarian pizzas are all fantastic!

Lisa McCarthy

Tia pie is yummy and has a kick. Cool posters and playlist. Support small business!

Vesper V

Om nom nom! So good. Hand tossed with extra mozzarella and garlic on top. Mmmhmmm.

Casey Keller

The cardiac arrest is my personal favorite, try the nickel nuggets !

Paige Pedersen

Sacre Bleu was delicious. VERY filling tho. Come with an appetite!

Renee Schaller

The deep fried mac and cheese is to die for!

Laura Nielsen

Add the instructions to "cook until firm" when ordering the Fetalicious for delivery to avoid getting a soggy pizza

Courtney Moore

Great food but double check your order before you leave if you get carry-out

Jon Larssen

Try their Mediterranean pizza . It's amazing!

Kent Ritchie

Like breakfast ? Like pizza ? Then you'll love the breakfast pizza .

Dougie Cyanide

Bigger booths = more seating now.

jill losser

One of my fav places for pizza cheese curds & bloody marys

Rafael Garcia Ribeiro

Awesome pizzas !

Amanda Carlson

The nickel nuggets are awesome.

Matthew LaForge

Whiskey Wednesdays: $3.50 for any whiskey .

Crystal Kraak

Awesome salads

Carlos Everman

Great food

Jason Hiestand

Try the Ranch Pizza w/walnuts. Oh my gosh!

Allison Garver

Nickel nuggets !

Tom

Great downstairs area for a private party.

Similar places nearby :

8.3
Pizza
Grampa's Pizzeria

Perfectly thin and crispy pizza. Also try the mozzarella appetizer, it had a unique vanilla fleur de sel flavor. - Kate Furman

8.8
Pizza
Ian's Pizza on State

Seriously the best pizza I have ever had. Crunchy great all around. Love it. - Ryan Davidson

7.4
Pizza
Papa Murphy's

They're not slow at all. Eat at home if ur so darn rushed. Good people watching and great pizza! - Gabriel Schroeder

8.9
Garden
Olbrich Botanical Gardens

Incredible free garden with beautiful outdoor displays. The indoor garden is also great, it does have a small fee though. Make sure to go to the Thai garden it is amazing. - Alexander Olcott

7.6
Grocery Store
Woodmans

24 hour grocery store is always awesome. The size & number of choices can be overwhelming, but you can always find what you need eventually. - Julie Champion

6.9
Dive Bar
Ohio Tavern

Delicious tacos & a decent beer list! Atmosphere wasn’t too busy on a Thursday night. Good vibes. - Clare