Anthony's NY Pizza

Anthony's NY Pizza is a pizzeria Seminole County Florida located in United States.

7 / 10
53
ratings
  • Phone

    (407) 657-5384

  • Website

    originalanthonyspizza436.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    439074346149152

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

1455 State Road 436 (at Howell Branch Rd) Casselberry , FL 32707 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 27


Keywords:

pizza extravaganza orlando bianca lively good for dates casual homemade food chicken town staff parking pepperoni lunch
frank cobb

Have been eating here for 7 years... Not once had a bad experience. All food is good an staff is great.

Dave Richard

This place was fantastic... I've lived in central Florida for 25 years and you can't find a better NY style pizza in the area.

Shawn Taylor

Everything is good here. Never had a bad meal

Ashlyn Williams

The soup only comes in a bowl so it is a meal or something to split. This is after two people working on a bowl for a while

Alo Gonzo

Love their extravaganza Stromboli...simply excellent. Pizza is very good also. Friendly staff , another locals favorite.

Barbara Dey

EVERYTHING! We start almost every weekend off with Anthony's! Bruce is a great guy and the staff is awesome! Keith & Barbara

Thomas Kirtley

Ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo with spinach , broccoli and chicken , and extra sauce. As well as mozz sticks . The mozz sticks were AMAZING, but the Alfredo was VERY bland, tasted like just pure cream.

Monica Agatstein

Most amazing Alfredo sauce ever! Everything is fresh and homemade - best Italian place in Orlando !

Lisa Bullion

Greek salad is wonderful!! Pizza is the best!!!

Johanna Belanger

Amazing food, fast service and always consistent...

Anna Gerrol

Extravaganza is amazing! And so r the mild wings with the cheeze pizza

Cyndy Murrieta

Best meat sauce in town !

Simon Yohe

Try the Pizza Bianca (white pizza )

Mariela Van Adelberg

Very good!!!

King Rook

Simply the best pizza in Orlando

Simon Yohe

Try the Spaghetti With Meatballs

Simon Yohe

Try the Garlic Knot

Simon Yohe

Try the pepperoni stromboli

Glenn Whelan

Plain cheese or pepperoni to die for:-)

Simon Yohe

Try the Buffalo Wings

Simon Yohe

Try the Pizza Bianca

Macy

Their Bianca style pizza is amazing!

Simon Yohe

Try the Greek Salad

Mike

Get the pizza , it's one of the best!

Omead Tabrizi

eggplant parmesan to die for!

Cindy B

Best lasagna in town !

Donna Rotondo Jendoubi

Pizza is ok...nothing special. Would I come back? No

Robert Amodt

This is some good pizza

Similar places nearby :

6.3
Pizza
Papa John's Pizza

Always good. Usually fast to - Chanse Strode

8.3
Pizza
Anthony's Pizza

Chicken Parm is excellent. My favorite in town and enough for two meals all for only ten bucks - Matt N

6.8
Pizza
Hungry Howie's Pizza

If carrying out, it's cheaper to get a LG cheese ($4.99 special) & add toppings than to buy any smaller pizza. - Carl D

8.9
Grocery Store
Publix

Very personable, helpful staff! - Jenn Lynn

7.0
Apparel
Ross Dress for Less

You never know what sort of treasures you will find! - Rachael Moore Kong

5.5
Big Box Store
Walmart Supercenter

What's not to love about Walmart it has just about everything but it's usually pretty busy so shop fast so you can have time to wait in line side note I prefer publix produce - kay