Peter Pan Diner

Peter Pan Diner is a diner Suffolk County New York located in United States.

7 / 10
0
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 665-1788

  • Website

    peterpandiner.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    660498067420210

  • Type

    Diner

Address

854 Sunrise Hwy Bay Shore , NY 11706 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Breakfast
Drinks Cocktails

Comments / 31


Katrina Poulos

Try the Mango Tango Wrap it has no mango at all on it but its delicious! Laura is a great waitress, funny and personable...puts you in a good mood!

Courtenay B💋

The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!

Jessica Palladino

Burgers are delicious, get the deluxe because the cole slaw is the best!

Luis Alicea

There's always great service, even during their dinner rush. The food isn't particularly expensive for a diner. I recommend the chicken caesar salad wrap with french fries and a chocolate shake.

Jessica Palladino

Feta cheese & tomato omelette is so good!

Reisal

Great food, quick service and courteous and energetic employees.

Chris Ullger

Looking for good food in Bat Shore then don't pass up the "Peter Pan Diner". Great food and awesome people!

Dia smith

The steak quesdilla is a must try... Love the food!

Stevie "G"ocinski

Best will make a point to stop by in the future 4 stars

Kay Sharee

He blueberry almond pancakes was fantastic

Tim Backus

Check out the grilled cheese menu

James Scully

Best Diner in the neighborhood by far

Taina Rivera-Vicari

You must try the New Champ its to die for!

Charlie Y

best gyro in the world and the jumbo burgers is always amazing

Ashley

Donna is great... French onion soup and blt is the way to go..

Joseph DeBello

Omg we need Christine back and Stella........the foods the same both the home feel is gone without Stella I'm going to start selling shirts saying we want Stella back...

Chris Ullger

Great place to get great food and share it with your family and friends.

Trever Polak

The gyro is good.

Bubsy

My Gyros was yummy.

Bubsy

This place is usually crowded.

Lucy Lanzarone

Tim is still the best and the food is great!!

Charlie Y

jumbo burger is always awesome

Bruce

Tuscany panini is top notch.

Amanda Miller

BEST French onion soup

Lucy Lanzarone

Ask for Tim.... Great service

Anthony Thomas

Ask for Karin....great service...better smile :)

Melissa

Love their panini

Jobu Jemas

Very pricy for a diner.

Patrick Carpenter

Order the sweet potato fries

Tim B

Ask for Marsha....

Sue J.

There waitress staff is very rude!!!

Similar places nearby :

7.9
Asian
Kumo Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

Another great dinner Cucumber roll , Godzilla Roll and Yellowtail Jalapeño Roll - CJ Gleeson

7.4
Steakhouse
J&R's Steakhouse

The stuffed flounder was pretty good. I enjoyed their salad also. But the cheesecake was awesome. - Dawn :o) DamnYourNosey!

8.1
Pizza
Blaze Pizza

AMAZING art pizza is mind blowing!!!!! And the make your own pizza choices are CRAZY AMAZING!!!! - Anonie Anonnon

8.0
Big Box Store
Target

Park behind the store toward the loading dock - Vicky C

8.2
Outlet Mall
Tanger Outlets Deer Park

Can be busy, but it's huge with tons of parking. Definitely worth a visit for some good deals. - Lloyd G

6.3
Mall
Westfield South Shore

Same trash mall that you knew and loved when you grew up but with a new nautical theme on the exterior - John Daskalakis