Tony's Pier Restaurant

My favorite spot on city island ; the food and the attitude of the workers are excellent!!! Fun place plus the best scenic area in back... Be ready for the crowd it's always there lol

I went there with my best friend and it was quiet a wait. I recommend going there earlier but it was worth the wait because the seafood was so delicious. I was so stuffed.

This place is great food is yummy staff is fast and efficient and the frozen drinks AMAZING I'm not a fan if the new look but the food is the same :)

Still my favorite. There a little wait now due to the current climate. Please be respectful and wear a mask they're doing there part do yours.

Remodeled after sandy. Broiled section was very slow this past Friday evening. Seafood pasta , baked clams and fried sheik basket. Cash only .

Love this place.. Great food fast service .. And the lines are very quick

Go with several people. There are different lines for different things such as Grilled food or Fried Foods and Beer GREAT beer list . Out door dinning watch out for Sea Gulls!

Everything is amazing here. They've really improved since Sandy hit them. New arcade and very clean .

The shrimp , yucca fries , and salad were all great! Also a fun, breezy , scenic spot!

Adored the fried shrimp the fried lobster was a bit salty. Also went for the seafood combo steer clear lacks flavor in every bite. The garlic bread was seriously oily and the tostones were dry.

Bring cash because it's only currency taken. If come accompanied, have friend grab the drinks. Lines are long on weekends.

Great seafood after a morning at orchard beach . Oysters on the 1/2 are awesome!

If you come in a group split buying duties at the different counters.

Everything fried is good!!!

I really enjoyed the flounder . Broiled takes too long.

Everything!

Food the same Drinks Still Strong and somebody was smoking some good shit in parking lot .... Long live Tony's !!!

Omg fried lobster

Stay away from the City Island Iced Tea if you're driving...and we know you're driving. How else would you get to Tony's?!?!

Loved the fried lobster and shrimp

Stay away from the City Island Iced Tea if you're driving...and we know you're driving. How else would you get to Tony's?!?!

Been coming here for 30 years and it's still the best

Fried shrimp

The ONLY place to go for soft shell crabs ...The best on the pier

Combo #1 best combo on town !!!!!

Only dine here during the day.

Best Shrimps and fries . Hands down!!

Henny colada

It was good stuff claim

Hope they re-open soon

The best rest. on the pier .. Cash only

Snow Crablegs 100%!

Fried shrimp

Great spot!

Don't eat here, its nasty as hell. I wouldn't wish my enemy this food.