Carmella's Cafe

From Italian classics to American staples to Utica specialties, we've got something for everyone. We've been a New Hartford favorite since 1985.

8 / 10
56
ratings
  • Phone

    (315) 797-3350

  • Website

    carmellascafe.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    carmellasrest

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Italian Restaurant

Address

8530 Seneca Tpke New Hartford , NY 13413 United States

Outdoor Seating No
Menus Happy Hour
Drinks Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 13


Keywords:

utica cheeseburgers happy hour chicken nachos good for groups lively sandwiches fresh baked breads french fries Caesar wrap meats good for dates big portions casual healthy food soup dinner parking lunch
Nick Souza

One of my favorite restaurants in Utica . I highly recommend their nacho because they are my favorite nachos I have ever had!

Kerry Casey

Absolutely amazing. The food is excellent. You need need to try the Utica special Chicken Riggies . Kathy the bartender is great. All I can say is wow! Wish I tried it sooner!

Sean Conboy

Chili Cheese Burger is the bomb. Fresh bread with flavored butter. Mmmm. Fresh made potato chips . We are talking winner here.

Jay Sumner 

Excellent place to go for happy hour . 2 for 1 drinks and a great munchy spread layer out. Everyday from 4-7.

Joe Sweet

The blu cheese burger is outstanding and so are the margaritas!

Anthony Fatiga

Two for one drinks and Italian dinners .

Sean Conboy

Kristen is amazing she rock give her money.

Ramon Aiello

Soup with free refills... Under 5 bucks!

Molly Luzak

Happy hour 2 for 1 2o'clock to 5o'clock.. Stop in check it out

Michele Sandock

The chickerina soup is fabulous!!!

Bill Egert

Toasted raviolis are an awesome appetizer .

Nick Brower

This place has gone down hill . Ate here at a slow time, could not even get a refill on our drink got our appetizers 30 seconds later out came the meal happens all the time

jim marble

Bad experience, cook shoulve stayed home. Ordered egplant parm and got chicken . When order was switched, egplant was tough and couldn't cut it.

Similar places nearby :

7.1
Italian
Olive Garden

The beef tortellini is awesome - John M.

8.2
Italian
Cafe Del Buono

They make their own homemade Caesar salad dressing and you can get it to go. I'm an expert Caesar salad dressing taster, and theirs is amazing. - jennwash sumner

7.5
Italian
Bella Cucina

delightfully cozy ambiance, great service, and ALL of their food is incredibly delicious! my favorite restaurant!❤️ - Mary Collins

6.0
Mall
Sangertown Square Mall

When I have to, I go shopping for every season. It holds many of the popular stores so you will be satisfied if you don't want to head towards Syracuse for shopping. - Judy

5.0
Big Box Store
Walmart Supercenter

Great values at all times... Only bad thing the produce is always picked over and moldy/rotting - Shanon Erickson

7.8
Movie Theater
Marquee Cinemas Orchard 14

Best theater around! Very clean and comfortable seats! You can lift the arm rest to cuddle! :) - Amy Squier