Popeye's on Lake Geneva

Family owned & operated since 1972. Located across from the public beach. Hosts SE Wisconsin's ONLY Outdoor Rotisserie & Area's Best Friday Fish Fry.

6 / 10
222
ratings
  • Phone

    (262) 248-4381

  • Website

    popeyeslkg.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    popeyeslkg

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    American Restaurant

Address

811 Wrigley Dr (btwn Cook & Broad St.) Lake Geneva , WI 53147 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Wheelchair Accessible Yes
Parking Street, Private Lot
Restroom Yes
Menus Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 68


Keywords:

scenic views good service chicken Bloody Marys all you can eat great value banana pie good for groups casual homemade food beer lunch dinner lakes alcohol liquor sampler platter window seats corned beef Rueben
Dominik Szewczyk

Best bet: Get the rotisserie sample platter and share with another person. Includes pulled pork , chicken , and beef kabobs . Includes soup , mashed potatoes and veggies . Enough for two.

Cherri Pierangeli Kasdorf

The menu has great choices, the food is delicious and window seats allow a lovely view of the lake !

Casey Mitroka

If you come here, request Justin to serve you. He goes above and beyond. We have a little one and he got us extra napkins and a little water cup without us even asking! He is fabulous!

Cherri Pierangeli Kasdorf

We love it there! Pretty view , good menu, good service and delicious food! Can’t go wrong! 🙂

Rami Hamzeh

Food , my fav is plate of two small portion of beef and chicken

Charles Sneed

The best seats are by the window, excellent view of the lake .

Sandi Robinson

The rotisserie chicken is the best ever! Prices are not that bad. I come here everyday when I am Lake Geneva!

Jeffrey Lansing

Okay. Kind of limited menu, okay burgers , plastic cups, a little pricey . But a nice view of Lake Geneva and lots of neat stuff to look at hanging on the walls. Middle of the road experience.

Phil Norder

Getting bent over is what is good here. 17 for nachos....we walked out b4 ordering...psssh!

Rhonda Scott

I am diagnosed Celiac, I started off the meal telling my waitress I have a Gluten Allergy - I was served gluten items, not once but twice! STAY AWAY my follow Gluten Free Warriors!!

Tasha Thicksten

Delicious clam chowder ! Rotisserie lamb was dynamite!

Christina Ramirez

Very good food! A little on the expensive side so be prepared to spend some money. No free refills also.

Nicole Garcia

The cheddar cheese broccoli soup is THE best. But the bowl is big enough for a family of 4!

terry m

Become a vip and the deals are great!

Jen Sparks

Yummy awesome at ST PATRICKS DAY!!!!! Corn Beef and Cabbage & GREEN BEER !

Kathleen Lebar

Try the cheese curds ! They're filled with yummy Wisconsin cheese !

Katie Heinemann

New favorite place in Lake Geneva. Rotisserie all day!!! Mmm!

Ivan Vega

It sure feels like fall out here and it's a perfect day for some comfort food .

Jennifer H

The fish fry is really good and all you can eat !

Lucy Yap

Amazing cheese curds and homemade ranch !

Brian Lambert

It's not Wisconsin without the Bloody Mary !

Biz Traveldude

Food is good, service is good. Building is beat.

joanne cook

Everything

Victoria Duda

Good soup , but that's about it here. Definitely one of the more overrated Lake Geneva restaurants , IMHO. Fish quality is horrible. Nice gift shop though!

Stacey Toibin

Go for the rotisserie stuff. Homemade banana pie is awesome.

ᴡ kluczyk

Chicken was good, broccoli soup was really good....though kabobs were a huge disappointment ...pulled pork was mushy and was in some weird gravy sauce ...

A R

Ask for Kelsey the waitress . The best

Jennie Payes

Best broccoli cheddar soup I've ever had!!!

Alena Bryhan

Ugh-undercooked chicken and under par service. 👎

Robb Hogan

Anniversary lunch !!

Sandy Patyk

The shrimp & baked Brie appetizer never disappoints. DELICIOUS!

C S

Not everything is offered from full menu when you sit outside.

Jamie Marie

Try the cheddar burger . So delicious!

John Fisher

Food is Ok, service is good, it's overpriced but it is on the lake so that is expected.

Kelly Lothian

The rotisserie lamb is unbelievably great!

Paula

Good food but pretty pricey for not a lot of food. Except the salads ! Those are huge.

Valerie Smith

Seasoning on kabobs and pork were good but meat was terrible. Fatty pork and dark meat chicken . Overpriced for inedible food. Broccoli soup was good.

Tom D

Broc cheese soup best in wi

Molly Noonan

Lamb sandwich is a must. Nomz!

Crysta Darr

My husband and I were disappointed. Burger had 1 piece of bacon and it says "stacked high". "Prime minister" Italian beef was not great either. Not a good meal to end the trip. Pricey for the quality

Steve Hansen

The Ruebens are amazing!

Kyle Graham

Tourist attraction . Food is overpriced and not amazing, but it's worth one trip for the experience!

Keith Gray

Save your money and eat somewhere else. Nice view , but that's about it. Food is overpriced and not very good. Waisted money here. $10 for cheese curd appetizer an the tastes like frozen ones.

Alex Casey

Horrible, go anywhere else the food is bad and the only thing here was the cheddar cheese soup , way over priced, I mean 14$ for nachos ?! Give me a break! The prices is over priced!

William Hunt

Beehive bizzy

Kerry Robbins

Do NOT get the prime rib . Very chewy- worst ever. The tenderloin kabobs were fabulous!

Teresa Hopp

Half price burgers on Monday

Christina Francy

Terrible service. Waited for 8 min to be acknowledged before we left. Been there before and too pricey for quality of food. Go somewhere else... Spare yourself the loud and mediocre food.

Jim Zeszutek

Sign up for their birthday club. 25 percent off entire bill!

Joe DeNucci

Chicken wrap is awesome.

Similar places nearby :

7.2
American
Flat Iron Tap

Beer / wine bar with good food. Kind of “steampunk “ feel to the place. - Jim Horsch

8.2
American
The Baker House

Fantastic Sunday Brunch - made to order omelettes AND pasta. Bring your appetite! - Tim P

8.0
American
Sopra Bistro

Great consistent Food with fun Chef and excellent cocktails! It is top of the town's food chain! Love it but do reserve as they book up - Emily Baker

8.3
Ice Cream
Kilwin's Chocolate & Ice Cream

Everything is delicious, from the fresh ice cream to the made in house chocolates and fudge... Enjoy it all!! - Danny Goodman

8.1
Harbor / Marina
The Riviera

A great view of the lake and a nice place to sit in front of and watch the world go by. - Jennifer J

7.2
Bar
Hogs & Kisses

Great bar to go to if you want to dance and have a fun night out with friends! Also, the bartenders make fabulous drinks. - Emily VandenHeuvel