Chef Michael's

"Where Chef's Go On Their Night Off" Warm, Inviting Restaurant Serving the Best of the Florida Keys Fish & Seafood. Serving dinner Nightly 5pm - 10pm, Sunday Brunch 10am - 2pm. Reservations are recommended.

9 / 10
67
ratings
  • Phone

    (305) 664-0640

  • Website

    foodtotalkabout.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    210629432357181

  • Type

    Seafood Restaurant

Address

81671 Old Highway (Overseas Highway) Islamorada , FL 33036 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Music Live Music
Drinks Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 28


Keywords:

hogfish chef michael shells key lime pie wine good for dates filet mignon healthy food good for groups nuts parking coconut sauce island dinner
Steve Schilling

Love Chef Michaels . So much so, that we ate there 3 nights in a row. Fantastic menu but you must try the Lion fish . Delicious and you are helping eliminate this threat to the reefs.

Gianna Nebbia

Best dining experience in the keys is at the bar at Chef Michaels . Dave keeps the wine and conversation flowing. The food is impeccable.

Bel Ragay

What a great little quaint resto in islamorada! Try the clam appetizer and the mahi mahi in Thai coconut sauce with shrimp .. really delicious!

K D

Sit at the bar and eat with David. Great wine list , fun conversation, and delicious food. A gem in Islamorada.

Esteicy

Can I please take a few seconds of your time and tell you that you NEED to eat here. Seriously! Just amazing. You're welcome.

Amanda

It was delicious! The lobster app was awesome. So was the hogfish .

Kel E Bee

The nut-encrusted hogfish is amazing! And the Key Lime Pie is simple & delicious - yummo!

Roger Gill

Get the tuna app and listen for what fish will hold up to the nuts topping because it is great. If Shell is working, sit in her section!

Patti Stanley

The bar seating is our choice! Love the service and the conversation.... We can always Catch up on the island sip-sip!

Dana Williams

Hog Fish Ponchetrain was mouth watering and the friendliest people run the place!

Matthew Robins

Hogfish , anything “mixed nuts ” style, and the key lime pie

Charlotte H

You MUST try the Key lime pie , it's awesome!

Elder Teixeira

The food is good. The people is nice. So, all is great.

Charlotte H

Amazing cuisine, try the hogfish

Kyia Herlth

The filet mignon is amazing, I get it every time I go!

Dennis McCarthy

The fresh fish is excellent and the people are great

Natalie Russell

The food, the wine ...delicious! If Shell is working, sit in her section. She is a heart.

FLAfamilyguru

This place was outstanding. Fresh cobia "ambassador" style - delicious.

Charlotte H

If Shell is working sit in her area, she is great!

Chef Michael's

.....Chef Michael's Restaurant will be closed Thanksgiving Day. Enjoy the holiday....eat well . See you all Friday.Regards,Michael & Crew

luca bino

The best restaurant we've founding Florida in 2 weeks! Thanx

Charlotte H

The lobster appetizer is amazing!!!

Patti Stanley

Fresh Yellow Tail !!!! LOVE it!

Dana Williams

Escargot was awesome!

Carrie Hook

Fried lobster appetizer was delish

Patti Stanley

The BEST 'fresh' you'll find A N Y W H E R E !!!

Yossi Kamar

Pricey food but good food nice restaurant ,

Patti Stanley

The best fresh!!!!

Similar places nearby :

8.6
Seafood
Lazy Days Restaurant

Amazing! By far the best seafood I had all week in Islamorada. But, make a reservation or you'll be waiting for awhile. - Caitlyn Fowles

8.6
Seafood
Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Best lively place to eat. Great live music, a must see if you are in Islamorada, very casual - Michael Perkins

8.5
Seafood
Snapper's Waterfront Restaurant And Saloon

wonderful food, wonderful service. worth the wait for an outdoor spot. great conch fritters. - Jessy King