New York City Pizza is a pizzeria Hilton Head Island located in United States.
81 Pope Ave #15B Hilton Head Island , SC 29928 United States
| Credit Cards | Yes (incl. American Express) |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
| Menus | Brunch, Lunch, Dinner |
| Drinks | Full Bar, Cocktails |
Their plain Margherita pizza is simply awesome. BBQ chicken pizza too. Our waiter was bit too much, bit too anxious, but altogether a great place!
Can't go wrong with a large cheese ; plus the calamari and zucchini sticks were great!
My family and I come here every time we come to Hilton head. It's an annual stop of FANTASTIC PIZZA ! Don't forge the pitcher of beer !
Everything is good. Great deal through Living Social.
Seriously good pizza and the mozzarella , basil , tomato sandwich tastes like summer.....so good!
Best pizza on HHI ! Excellent service every visit.
Caprese is great. Chicken parmesan sandwich great. Lasagna kinda sucks.
I tired to use the check in special and the owner didn't even know what foursquare was. The food was great
Calimari was salty...breadsticks okay. But pizza !? Freaking awesome!
My waitress said that they don't actually accept AmEx, which is ironic considering the 4sq special
Best pizza on HHI - but consider ordering ahead because it can be a long wait
Pizza is delicious and thin.
By far the worst pizza I've ever had it was almost like they used watered down tomato soup and very poor service
Buffalo Chicken pizza !
Deep Dish is delicious!
Ridiculously good pizza
Best dinner all week in Hilton Head!
Throw some pizza in your pie hole
Amazing pizza !
Penne rivazza.
Dont order the mimosas . Tastes like tang and cooks.
Not very good carryout . Breadsticks cold and salad was warm. Showed up early to pick up. Kids did care for pizza either.
Definately worth it
Mediocre pizza served by badly trained college kids. Pass on this place.
Very slow service!
Best New York style pizza on Hilton Head and Lasagna with full size meatball is excellent as well. Never disappointed. - Levelbest
The pizza is actually very good, has a slightly sweet crust and delicious (stringy) cheese. We always get it at least once while on the island. - C Snoke
Best pizza ever and very kid friendly. Don't miss the Greek salad and great beer selection. - James S
It's a beautiful beach, kids can play in the sand, great for laying out! You can rent an umbrella and chairs for the entire day for just $32. - Jared F.
Java Joes is my new favorite! Fresh Produce is super cute. Big Bamboo is also very tasty. Piggly Wiggly is a must see. The Shell Shop!!! I saw a magician on Monday evening as well. - Kylie S-B
A secret gem on the island. Fresh seafood@mostly local fishers It must be good as they are celebrating fifty years on the island - Colonel Mustard