Ice Cream Cottage
Ice Cream Cottage is a ice cream parlor Suffolk County New York located in United States.
1590 Montauk Hwy (at Herkimer St.) Mastic , NY 11950 United States
| Outdoor Seating | Yes |
Comments / 17
Keywords:
John Pastore has been making ice cream at his little "cottage" in Mastic since 1980, serving an unparalleled variety of cones . Try the chocolate overdose or the black forest ! Read more
Best ice cream . You must stop if your in area. Had many flavors, all great. Just had chocolate overdose , so good!
Cake batter ice cream topped with cannoli ice cream in a waffle cone .. I'm in heaven. Best ice cream on long island
Jelly ring, rainbow cookie , and cherry chip are my favorites!!
Had a salted caramel ice cream on a pretzel cone and it was amazing
Sometimes it can be a long wait but its definitely worth it!
Vanilla choc chip and chocolate with rainbow sprinkles . Best homemade ice cream around here
Best Cherry Vanilla ice cream I ever had!
Cherry Chip is great but you can't really go wrong with any of the flavors.
This place is always packed! The wait is totally worth it.
Love that place, always a happy girl after a trip there 😀
Everything!
The cake batter and canoli ice cream is to die for!
Bartman in a small waffle cone .. Yum!
Strawberri shortcake icecream was good..
The smores mash is amazing.
Take a pint home.
Similar places nearby :
Place United States » New York » Suffolk County » Mastic