Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Owned & Operated by the Original Umbertos of New Hyde Park Since 1965

9 / 10
130
ratings
  • Phone

    (516) 221-5696

  • Website

    umbertosny.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    umbertosny

  • Facebook

    124163004318991

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

1180 Wantagh Ave (Jerusalem Ave) Wantagh , NY 11793 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. Visa & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Music Yes
Dining Options Bar Service, Take-out, Delivery
Parking Public Lot
Restroom Yes
Menus Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 41


Keywords:

pizza pazzo lively grandma pie good for groups good for a quick meal casual good for dates sausage rolls healthy food chicken Caesar salad good for working Sicilian well broccoli rabe grandma slices red peppers dinner olives
William Huba

The Pazzo is great - the crust is super crispy on the outside but still a little chewy inside, sauce is light, toppings are flavorful. Only complaint is that it was a little on the greasy side.

Valerie S

On-the-go or eating in: either way, Umberto's is the top choice. Amazing pizza , as well as classic Italian dishes that hit the spot every time! My family's favorite.

Lloyd G

Amazing food, great decor and good service . They have two sections, one for take-out and one for sit-down waiter service. Definitely try the pizza , the grandma and Sicilian slices are fantastic!

Robert Katz

This is my favorite pizza spot in Wantagh the food is always fresh and the staff here is amazing most of whom I've known for years

Dan Cummo

The pizza is the best I’ve eaten in Nassau County , & their sausage rolls are great!!!

Mike Mostransky

It's seriously hard to go wrong here. The Grandma slice is the best and has won awards. The Buffalo Chx and Broccoli/Sausage Rabe are two more of my favorites as well . These guys make the best pizz

Michele Dowling

It's a really good restaurant and reasonably priced. It's good family restaurant . The pizza is also excellent here.

Billy D

Great tasting food. Home of the Giant Stuffed Artichoke .

Jordanna Oliveira

Grandma’s pizza all the way!

Jimmy Docs

There is no pizza like Umbertos... Whether it's here, Franklin Square, or Floria Park ... Been to all three. It is pizza Heaven for any Italian.

Jarel Hill

Yoo! Their grandma pizza is unreal! Will always come here if I’m in the area.

Nicole H

Deep dish pizza is amazing!! Always have the best food & service!

Brian McLoughlin

Love their chicken sorrentino and chicken francese . Great pizza as well .

Roe Napolitano

Like all the umber tons. Food is awesome

JohnAnthony Eletto

Best pizza on Long Island . Competes with spots in Brooklyn.

Mike Mostransky

You must have the Grandma pizza and try the Pazzo

Mike Mostransky

My new fave, pizza pazza - roasted red peppers , crumbled sausage & kalamatta olives

Chris Pizzaia

Get the grilled chicken hero with broccoli rabe ....awesome

Greg Yager

If you go on Fridays during lent get there by 4:00

Susan Perna

Love the deep dish pizza jere

Pamela

The Sicilian pizza well done is delicious.

Jay Shah

Grandma pizza is oh so good!

Barbara Reggio

I love the buffalo chix pizza and the chix marsala pizza

Lauren Christopher

Only good place to get New York style pizza !!

Katie C

New pizza Margarita pizza is amazing!!

Chris Ferina

The best Grandma 's pie ever!

Mike Fatone

The buffalo chicken is beyond delicious and not too greasy.

Josef Arnold

The deep dish pizza is incredible!

Michael Letscher

Great food

Bryan McMullin

Pazzo slice is fantastic.

erica-u nicorn

Chicken Marsala pizza

Giang B

Grandma pie

Darren

The grandma pizza was a tad oily but good nonetheless

Anna Jarzebiak

23 hungry Italians? Come here!

Naytoilltoreal Ham

Best Italian food ever

Mike Mostransky

the best Grandma Pie evah'!

Mike Mostransky

Try a fried cappellini

Mike Mostransky

Try a fried cappelini

Mike A

Need to try the grandmas !

Marisa Oxios

Shrimp oreganata yummy

Julie A

deep dish pizza

Similar places nearby :

8.4
Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

The wings are great, my family and I always enjoy the meatball and roasted cauliflower pizza. - Rebecca Scotto

7.1
Pizza
Brooklyn Square Pizza

Try a new slice every time you go! Deliciousness all around! - Colleen Grodotzke

7.8
Pizza
Phil's Of Wantagh

They have gluten free pizza & pasta! Very accommodating. - Lillian Huang

7.0
Pharmacy
CVS pharmacy

DO NOT GET YOUR PASSPORT PHOTO DONE HERE! Post office said it was taken too far back so I had I get it retaken there! Also-- you can smile in your passport photo-- don't listen to CVS! - Kelley

9.1
Gourmet
Iavarone Brothers

Too many items to list but I'll plug my faves - olives, sushi, chx parm, eggplant parm, fresh mozz, breads, cannolis, cakes, cookies, awesome steaks, soups, cheeses, oils, produce - more nxt time - Mike Mostransky

6.2
Donuts
Dunkin'

They've got the best coffee, & I love their egg white, veggie, flatbread sandwiches. - Dan Cummo