Panico's Bistro

Panico's Bistro is a italian restaurant West Cape May located in United States.

7 / 10
55
ratings
  • Phone

    (609) 884-7170

  • Website

    panicosbistro.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Italian Restaurant

Address

422 Broadway West Cape May , NJ 08204 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Drinks Wine, BYO

Comments / 20


Keywords:

BYOB big portions great value Italian food wine desserts dinner peanut butter lemon staff
Amy Pegarella

This is a must in Cape May, the Clam lemon cello is amazing, so is the peanut butter bomb dessert

Scott Lerner

Very good, if you can't decide what to get terry the trio. The terapita was a must have first plate.

Kelly Fergusob

The burrata appetizer is INCREDIBLE.

Mike Straub

We go here every year we come to Cape May! Great place!

Cally See

Delicious pasta but huge portions . Order family style or plan on having leftovers!

Lauren Suit

Good Italian food in an old church . High ceilings means it can get noisy . Specialty pizzas are excellent. Byob

Laura Stefankiewicz

Spicy seafood entree is delicious!! I will defiantly be back again & hopefully soon!

Amanda Knight

Ask for Jennifer. Best waitress ! Awesome service and awesome personality.

Charlene Moore

The food is delicious big portions . The service is alittle slow. Had a wine issue with the cork.

Jim L

If you're feeling spicy , go for the diavolo pizza .

Amanda Knight

Very small waiting room. Also have to wait outside and they don't take reservations . Great place they just need heaters for winter

Heather

Great food, large portions . Wait staff could be better. BYOB

Angela Giorno

Really yummy food here and a BYOB !!

Amy Sturgill

Love the food and you get lots of it. Good pizza and cheese balls.

amanda w

Ladies bring a sweater the AC is pumping!

Ann Bradshaw

Long wait , even with call ahead seating. Not the best service. Had to ask several times for water and bread refills.

Mike M.

Refills are NOT free. $5.00 sharing charge.

Pete Evans

It is loud , but the food is good. BYOB to handle the noise :)

Monica Takacs

Byob , opens at 5pm

Donna Hoffay

Took over 2 hours to get pizza . We had a large crowd but come on! Not even the peak season. Can’t imagine what it will be like then! Stay away unless you want to spend the night!

Similar places nearby :

7.9
Italian
Sapore Italiano

We had a wonderful dinner. We had some of the gnocchi and some of the spaghetti, both were amazing! Service was wonderful. Also it is BYOB and there is a liquor store right next door. - Matthew Fronheiser

Pizza
Brother's II Pizzeria

They have free delivery - Aj Stelacio

7.4
Restaurant
Exit Zero Filling Station

Good place with an indoor bar and nice outdoor area to kick back and relax. Dog friendly - G T

8.7
Mall
Washington St. Mall

Quaint New England atmosphere, pleasant shops restaurants and bars. Come here for a lovely evening after the beach. ⛵ - Filter Scan / Sean

8.8
Hotel
Congress Hall

the comment about the rooms not being level is accurate...either way likely the best place to stay in cape may. very nice atmosphere. - Jason Kusner

8.0
Ice Cream
Kohr's Bros

A family favorite! Not many flavors to choose from, but the orange and vanilla swirl is heavenly. - Paula Focazio