The Pie of Port Jefferson
The Pie of Port Jefferson is a pizzeria Suffolk County New York located in United States.
216 Main St (at E. Main Street) Port Jefferson , NY 11777 United States
| Reservations | No |
| Credit Cards | Yes |
| Wi-Fi | No |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
| Drinks | Wine |
Comments / 22
Keywords:
Undecided? Give the Di Parma and Casino pizzas a go, although I don't think you'll be disappointed in any of the pies from here.
The mixed green salad with Gorgonzola cheese , cucumber , red onion and toasted crusted walnuts was Fabulous! A large serving for ten bucks. Great pizza and meatball subs too.
One of the best pizzas in the area, pleasant service and good atmosphere
Great food, reasonable prices, great service & a very family friendly spot for a sit down meal in the heart of town . We love coming here!
Amazing place! Sangria , pizza and cannoli are very tasty! :)
Pizza is Italian indigenous and it’s amazing! Great sangria !!!
In addition to making a mean brick oven pizza , the staff at the pickup counter was the friendliest!
We dubbed The Pie as one of the 10 "Long Island 's best pizza pies " worth the drive! Read more
Pizza is great, sangria amazing
My favorite table is the little one in the front window. The restaurant is rather loud , but this table seems to be the best.
One of the best pizzas . Great service
Great family place ..try the clam pizza !
Classic thin brick oven pizza . Yea its on the pricey side, but worth it.
Every time I come here I remember how lax the service is...after I order my food and don't see the server until they deliver the bill. Everything else is great though!
Some of the best pizza in Port Jeff .
Best pizza in Port Jeff . Tad expensive but expected in a tourist area.
This isn't a tip but there's hot waiters ;)
Nice place!
Best garlic knots around.
This thin crust Chicky Cheeses is way too loud and disorganized for the high prices.
Bomb thin crust pizzas !
Pizza looks good .. Too thin tho
Similar places nearby :
Best pizza in area. Always fresh, always tasty - Frank Caramanica
They have great Greek food not even on the menu! Love it! - Coleen Watkins
Order anything on the menu, it's all good. Especially the garlicky garlic nots - Mike Seilback
Nice city to visit in the summer. A lot of shops, restaurants with great seafood and a new Brewery _ Port Jeff Brewery. I had lunch at Zpita and the food was delicous... - David Montalvo
Orang Mango Smoothie is the way to go! Tastes almost like Jamaica :) ps: barely any seating here, but great service! - Dustin Wingate
Place United States » New York » Suffolk County » Port Jefferson