Which Wich Superior Sandwiches

Which Wich has 50+ wiches and 60+ toppings

8 / 10
102
ratings
  • Phone

    (317) 580-9424

  • Website

    whichwich.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    whichwich

  • Facebook

    116252505070353

  • Type

    Sandwich Spot

Address

1430 W Carmel Dr Ste 140 Carmel , IN 46032 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch

Comments / 46


Keywords:

sandwiches wicked milkshakes good for a quick meal chocolate chip cookies chicken meats bacon pickles restaurants salads lunch yellow mustard bananas Dijon provolone parking red onions mozzarella avocado
Sarah Burnette

Currently my favorite place! For like, $5/sandwich, you just can't beat it. Refillable cups rock. Chips and drink are reasonable. I'm loving the terriki (sp?) Chicken and the wicked . Soo good.

Jade Williams

Darcy, the owner, is amazing. If you get a chance to talk to her she's so sweet. Order the corned beef and pastrami with horseradish and sauerkraut . It'll change your life...

James Buckhorn

Ask for the Meatball Grinder , you will not be disappointed. John is one of the top 5 sandwitch makers in the Midwest

Rajan Kapur

Fill out the survey while waiting for your sandwich & show the completion code to the cashier . They give you a FREE oven warmed cookie !

Courtney Rae Puckett

Sandwiches can be made vegan . The wheat bread contains honey , but otherwise they can easily be made with no animal byproducts!

CORY Meyer

This place is amazing. Staff is courteous and prompt and its fun to try new things. Plus the kids feel like they are in charge.

Christopher Martz

Must try the Elvis Wich. Peanut butter , bacon , honey , and banana . OMG

Elisa Meredith

They have avocados here :) and the service is always superior as is the sandwiches of course!

Anthony Paladino

Draw a picture on the back of your bag and you'll know where your sandwich is in the prep line .

Arcy

Try the Italian Grinder with dijon , red onions , hot peppers , and oregeno. The chocolate chip cookie (with a combo) is amazing.

Matt Guldberg

Hula with bacon and spicy ranch-thank me later

Cyndi Howard

Fun way to order food. The staff was very helpful and courteous!

Haleigh Castino

Try the Italian Grinder , toasted with provolone , yellow mustard , lettuce and pickles !

Jason Williams

The Surf & Turf (crabmeat and roast beef ) was fantastic. Sandwiches only $5.10 or make it a combo for $2 and some change. Definitely beats Subway

Tiffany Schutt

My fave is the chicken italiano with mozzarella and fat-free italian dressing ...yum!

Chrisito

So disappointed. Arrived at 6:30 on a Sunday evening. They are open until 7, but all the chairs were upsidedown on the tables and we were turned away. A bunch of jerks working here.

Duke McCain

A thousand times better than subway, only slightly more expensive , and they have milkshakes !

Katy DeWitt

They have great vegetarian options ! My husband and I love this place! :)

Laura Spears

$3 regular wiches today to celebrate our 3rd birthday at the Carmel store!!

Arcy

Add cole slaw to kick it up a notch! You will wonder how you ever did without it. Amazing.

Jade Williams

Darcy, the owner, is the best! Get the grinder !

Blakeleigh King

Their chocolate shakes are very yummy!!!!

Everest Castillo

Taking yummy to a higher level !❤️❤️

anfrey

Go with the pesto !

Nancy Milstone

Olive salad is amazing.

Alanna Alboher-ray

Banana and pineapple milkshake !!!!!! Amazing

Duke McCain

Make your girlfriend wait for the sandwiches while you leave tips on 4sqr

Emily Albers

Best Strawberry milkshake around!

James Buckhorn

The managers here are great!

Alanna Alboher-ray

Turkey sandwich extra meat hot!!

Valerie Atwell

The GYRO is awesome!

Michael Marley

Jay's tip is way off. Which wich is heaven in a bag. Penn station is shit in a bag.

John

The Italian grinder is my current favorite.

Marc Edouard Jean Marie

Evrything!

Patrik Trent

Delicious.

Fritz Mccorkle

Very superior sandwiches .

Elizabeth Borlik

Try the caprese--delicious

Rew Van Wyck

Love their hummus .

Sue Beetham

I miss the SPAM

Steve Johnson

Try 1000 Island on your Wicked . Mmmmmm....good.

Jack Kessler

Try it all.so many combinations

Jay Trauring

It's Penn Station in a bag!

Rick N9GSU

Decent, but I find it overpriced.

Erick Cavalcanti

The Wicked ! Do it.

Jason Cash

Try out Which Wich

Juarez Barbosa

muito bom....

Similar places nearby :

7.0
Sandwich Spot
Penn Station East Coast Subs

Best fries at the Carmel location. - Steve Hartsock

5.9
Sandwich Spot
Subway

Good chopped salad....bit expensive though. - Dana Davis

8.7
Sandwich Spot
Greek Tony's

The Italian Sub and the Pizza Sub are amazing!! I have been coming here since I was a kid.... They haven't changed too much and I like that continuity with their beginnings... :) - Fr. Joshua Janko

6.7
Supermarket
Meijer

Good selection of stuff, good prices. Produce quality is spotty though - Katherine Corbin

8.2
Ice Cream
Yogurtz

Awesome place! A TON of variety from yogurt flavors to different toppings. - Jessica Howard

7.8
Chinese
Panda Express

I recommend the Chicken with Mushrooms and the Honey Walnut Shrimp. And the Lipton Diet Peach Green Tea is a surprisingly tasty zero calorie option. - Paul Lucas