Pick A Bagel

Pick A Bagel is a bagel shop Theater District New York located in United States.

8 / 10
740
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 582-8333

  • Website

    pickabagelny.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    pickabagel8th

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Bagel Shop

Address

891 8th Ave (at W 53rd St.) New York , NY 10019 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch

Comments / 166


Keywords:

bagels breakfast food casual flagels good for a quick meal authentic lively sandwiches coffee great value salads cream cheese bakeries eggs bright espresso good for singles bacon chicken crowded
Haya Al Dossary

Delicious, soft bagel , plenty of variety and they bake them all day, a lot of spreads, sandwiches and salads , but you leave smelling like food

Ally Furai

Best salad mix-ins ever! Fresh mozz balls with basil ! If you are feeling naughty get the low-fat chicken salad on a scooped out bagel (creates a safe environment for your chicken salad )!

Heidi Henry

Hooray for vegan options ! Happy to find this place just around the corner of my hotel . Got a bagel with tofu cream cheese for breakfast every morning. Don't be worried about the line . It moves fast!

The Corcoran Group

The flagels here are awesome, as are the wide variety of cream cheese options. A bit on the expensive end as far as bagels go, but they're still worth it here.

Jenna Hahn

Pick a bagel had the best bagels I’ve ever had. The bagel was nice and toasted on the outside and soft on the inside. Even had tofu cream cheese that went perfect with my blueberry bagel .

Guillaume P

Ok. As a montrealer I'd always defend Montreal's bagels . But here I finally understood why NYC's Bagels can be delicious as well . Great choice of fresh bagels and combos. Perfect for breakfast .

MRTR O.

A perfect place to have breakfast . Amazing bagels , nice breakfast menu options. Just a note; be ready for the crowd.

Burcu Karadayı

Can't believe that I've discovered this place on my final day in NYC. Really delicious and various breakfast options .

Jade Binette

Good verity of food. Got the bagel with a small espresso . Good breakfast to start on a cold January morning

Jeremy Jacobowitz

By far the best bagels in the area! A true new York bagel with loads of options!

Andrew C

Seems like the best bagel place in midtown west / Columbus circle area... Very solid bagel with cream cheese and good iced coffee !

Matt Brooks

Their poppy seed bagels are amazing especially with a #3 breakfast special !

Jeff S

If you've never had a blueberry bagel , I really think you need to. What's not to love about a bright purple bagel ?

Alex Kasemir

The lines are quite long but you can get a get a great breakfast sandwich on any bagel . I recommend the whole wheat everything !

Kate Hailey

Varied schmears, good bagels , salads and other healthy options as well .

Ingrid Stenquist

Gets pretty crowded . Bagels are soft and chewy. Cream cheese is standard. Their lox is amazing but pricey as midtown goes. I'm still more partial to bklyn bagels .

Matt Ferrari

Long lines in morning but worth the wait. They have a lot more than just bagels and it's worth a try

Too busy during the morning, however, excellent place for creating your own preferred bagel . We simply love it.

mary nah

Excellent bagel but if you take with salmon it Will be 12$!

Lauren Rodas

One of the best lunch or breakfast spots in the area! Bagels are cheap and delicious

Ann-Marie Tang

Scallion cream cheese was yummy. Got the baker’s dozen and everyone loved the bagels !

Jeff Mendels????hn

The two cashier women are great and efficient. I can't say the same for the rest of the staff who isn't. The bagels are decent and the spreads are fair (mainly because I think they're left out all day

Sabrina A

Bagels are great, but order of operations is a mess. If you order a coffee make sure to show your receipt to the people at the far end to make it.

Viajandolavidaloca

Fun fact: they have tofu cream cheese - not bad but not exactly cream cheese . If you’re dairy-free like me, it’s a nice to have.

Jinnie L

salmon with cream cheese on everything bagel is to die for :) breakfast bagel is yummy too♥

Ghadah Ababtain

I like the everything bagel .. I choose it with chicken it was so delicious

Gillian

Nova salmon on an everything bagel was great. Service was very fast even on a busy day.

Francisca Nunes de Almeida

Best bagel in my entire life! The everything bagel is really tasty!

Brittany Goodwyn

The Whole Wheat Everything bagel is to die for. By far one of the best bagels around.

Michael Chang

Best deal for a whole wheat everything bagel with scallion cream cheese

Julie Soscia

Some of the best bagels in NYC - try the rainbow bagel or the Lox .

Julie Soscia

Some of the best bagels in NYC - try the rainbow bagel or the Lox .

Alex Ravenel

Good, if unspectacular bagels . Still, very good option for a quick breakfast in the area.

Corey Wall

Pretzel salt bagel with sun-dried tomato cream cheese

James Nightingale

Supreme pastrami on everything bagel , so gooooood!! ????

Julie Soscia

Some of the best bagels in NYC - with plenty of amazing spreads.

Vito Tartaglia

Good bagels , coffee (espresso too, much better than starbucks). Fair prices

Jenkin A.

Get their flat bagels . Add in the tofu scallion filling. Wow!

Alexis YSY

Everything whole wheat bagel , blueberry bagel , garlic bagel . Lox spread , vege spread

Heath Bennett

Very fresh with lots of options

Beverley Hutchins

Many good selections for salad toppings-- I'm impressed! Having the option of a smaller salad is a plus.

Joe Cheskin

Whole wheat everything bagels with butter and a coffee . All you need, really.

Sherry Dean

I'm there once a week for "low fat " tuna salad that's great !! Bagels aways fresh..

Elizabeth Lee

Love their bagels here. Flagels are ok, but bagels are the best.

Mike Hopkins

The best cream cheese I've ever had. Amazing bagels to boot.

Ahmad Mal

Sesame bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon .

Charlie Marie

Whole wheat everything Flagel is the way to go for great breakfast sandwiches .

Karen

Bagels made fresh every day. Good selection of spreads.

Christine Taylor

Great BLT on a bagel . Everything is fresh and delicious.

Jon W

Awesome bagels but they have yet to get my order right on the first try. Allow time for a remake

Similar places nearby :

9.1
Bagels
Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Co.

Share a bagel with cream cheese with a friend. Very large bagel with a wallop of cream cheese enough for a container full at our local bagelry. - N K

8.5
Bagels
Corner Bagel Shop

Always consistently good with fresh, doughy bagels. The service here is also wonderful, which is very rare for any bagel shops on the UES. I will always pop in here on the weekends. - Paige C

7.6
Bagels
Mike's Bagels

Mozzarella tomato and basil on an everything bagel is amazing. Staff is always friendly as well. - Amanda

9.7
Park
Central Park

Great park to walk and bike. Enjoyable. Always something going on. Kayak, merry go round, zoo, concerts, playground - Angi W

9.3
Art Museum
Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

Wonderful museum and art-collection, nicely presented! We had a little drink afterwards in their very cosy cafetaria. We were served super-friendly!!! - Linda De Wolf

7.4
Coffee Shop
Starbucks

great service and also great staff in this branch ! - jina.