Mattheessen's
Mattheessen’s has two locations on the world famous “Duval Street” in Key West, Fl. They feature homemade goodness using only the finest ingredients to make their cookies, ice cream, key lime pie and marble slab fudge.
419 Duval St (btwn Eaton & Fleming St) Key West , FL 33040 United States
| Reservations | No |
| Credit Cards | Yes (incl. American Express) |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
| Menus | Dessert |
Comments / 34
Keywords:
Ice Cream , Cookies , Fudge , Catering , Chocolate chip , Peanut butter with chocolate fudge , Sugar cookies with sprinkles , Freshly baked goods , Freshly made sweets
Cookies , Fudge , Key Lime Pie , Ice Cream , Chocolate Chip , Peanut Butter , Toasted Coconut , Mint Chip , Vanilla , Chocolate
The absolute best ice cream and sorbet on the island . They also ship their delicious cookies at a reasonable price
The giant cookies are absolutely delicious. With big cookies you expect terrible. But these are so good.
Ask for a free sample of fudge…they’re delicious!
Awesome mint chocolate chip .... Told them about a cute little white cat that followed me, gave a cookie to give to the cat. Soooo sweet!!!
The chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick feeds definitely more than 2.
Own made cookie for 6,50$, but a good one
Everything- so yummy ????????
Best cookies on the island , and not overpriced.
Key lime pie is tart bit also so sweet!
Best Homemade IceCream And Fudge Ever!!!!!
Cookies are nothing short of amazing!
Yummy ice cream , one of the best fresh strawberry icecreams :)
Key lime pie was to die for ????????
Cookies and ice cream
make sure you get a cookie ! they're huge but really good.
Amazing brownie sundae ! It's huge!
Yeah I wouldn't buy anything from this guy. He's sooo cheap he turns on his A/C right around 4-5pm. This ice cream shop was sooo freaking hot that I think the ice cream was melting. CHEAP ASS!
ice cream .....do it. brownie ??? DO IT...TWICE!
The cookies aren’t good at all. Save your calories. The chocolate chips lacked flavor. Didn’t really taste like chocolate . A little too dry as well .
Cookies Fudge Key Lime Pie Ice Cream
Great cookies
Order online and enter code matts10 for a discount on cookies and fudge .
They make THE most amazing chocolate chip cookie you'll ever eat.
Try the half pound cookies
Lemon pie ...
Looking for catering for a
Chocolate covered key lime pie
Cookie Shop
Amazing chocolate chip cookies
Até então o melhor cookie que já comi na vida foi lá e é o de chocolate branco com macadâmia . O de manteiga de amendoim também é ótimo!
Des cookies fantastiques, et une tarte citron exceptionnelle
Des cookies énormes et délicieux !
Similar places nearby :
Get the giant cookie. It's delicious - Hollie Sick
Their key lime pie is really popular here! - Shn Juay
The Mamey is the BEST! Sweet and creamy with a honey and almond aftertaste. - Jason Gainey
Atmosphere, entertainment, souvenirs, and of course the infamous Sloppy Joes. Don't miss it! - Jill Brailey
Great location to watch the sunset. Street performers are quite entertaining and talented as well. - Lisa
Great place to visit! Can't go wrong with any option. My personal favorite is the miami vice! - Krista Chamberlain
Category Dining and Drinking » Dessert Shop » Ice Cream Parlor
Place United States » Florida » Monroe County » Key West