Ice Castle Sweet Shoppe is a dessert shop Fire Island located in United States.
319 Bay Walk Fire Island , NY 11770 United States
Menus | Dessert |
The candy selection is excellent. The ice cream selection is adequate. The staff is funny.
I recommend the cotton candy ice cream and chocolate walnut fudge - although not together!
Fly fishing fudge is a great flavor.
Lots of old school candy ... Where else can you find bubble tape and runts??
Giant chocolate covered gummy bears !
Awesome ice cream . :-)
Root beer floats !
My first job was here. I love this family! This family owned restaurant/bakery has been an Ocean Beach staple for decades. The giant chocolate chip cookies were always a favorite childhood treat. - Meredith A
Best ice cream on the island. Raspberry cream and coconut almond are good. - Morgan Polotan
The second best ice cream shop in town. Have the muddy sneakers ice cream. - Mark Heyert
I like where you heads at with the Mint Chip! Also get late night pizza at Matthew's.....Oh so good! - Clell Hall
The peanut butter & jelly wrap is AWESOME!!! Lobster rolls are great, too. Delish food & great drinks. - Ariel Elizabeth