Der Dutchman

Fried chicken, tender roast beef, real mashed potatoes, Amish noodles and a variety of homemade pies are waiting for you at Der Dutchman. All menu items are available for carry-out. Visit our on-site bakery to take home delicious cookies, pies, breads, cakes and donuts.

9 / 10
243
ratings
Address

3713 Bahia Vista St Sarasota , FL 34232 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 48


Keywords:

amish buffet broasted chicken good for groups desserts salad bar fruit pies cake casual breakfast food healthy food great value pastries bakeries waffles hash browns short ribs ice cream restaurants dinner
Frank Maggio

I you're looking for comfort food , then this is the place to go!! Amish cooking at its best. The buffet is what most people come for, but the menu is also good. The fried chicken is amazing!!

Lynda Judevine Leslie

Love the short rib special on Friday night and the chicken is awesome! Great salad bar and hot buffet . I don't think I had anything I didn't like! The atmosphere is non existent but the food makes up

Laura Williams

Come Friday and Saturday (dinner ) for the Amish Date Pudding . It is delicious and not really a pudding at all. It is a cake mashed up with caramel sauce and homemade whipped cream . Yum!

Sergio Novelli

Good buffet choice. Menu with a good choice and food is very natural and tasty. Overall excellent prices

Deborah Clifford-Hoedt

We love to go down from Tampa once in a while to eat. LOVE IT THERE.. Food is GREAT. we get the buffet . yummy

victoria true

So the buffet selection entree wise a lunch is narrow. So what. I'm a vegetarian with occasionally fish murder. Doesn't matter, this was Spook good.

Gary Keller

The broasted chicken is great. It is chicken cooked in a pressure cooker to lock in juices . Also check their deserts in the foyer. Many are half price.

Merab Favorite

They have the best cakes and best prices..... Cheaper than Publix and far superior!

Erich K

The perfect family place to fill your pie hole with Amish goodies.

Amber Medico

Their buffet is always great, authentic comfort food that reminds me of the holidays all year round.

Hew Matt

Buffet was nice with a large assortment . Baked pastries and cakes are always amazing.

Linda Krysinski

Best breakfast I have ever had....waffle with fresh strawberries and whipped cream with sausage patties .

Michael Leer

You can’t go wrong with the buffet

Joy Mislevy

EVERYTHING! LOVE COMING HERE ENJOYING BUFFET ! SERVICE EXCELLENT!

Ajayi Family

The chicken the friendly staff the dessert , it was all great

Will Luera

The buffet was amazing. Well worth the price.

Roxy Shaw

Open faced roast beef ! Yummy. Also love the banana cream pie

Donna Vliet

Recently remodeled! Home cooked food and wonderful desserts ????

Chris Tomlin

Everything is good. Broasted Chicken the best!!!

Ann Jo

Ask for gravy on the side with an entree. Also, white dinner rolls beat wheat!

Gary Sonnee

Food is homemade and the buffet is excellent

StormRazor

Great buffet and deserts ! Good home cooking

Kaelea Parisi

I love this place!!! Staff is awesome food is outstanding!! The buffet is my fav!!

Christina Krulik

Delicious! Cheesy potatoes . Yum! Clean and friendly .

Kay Wolfe

Best food. Everything is delicious :-)

Cengiz Turkmen

Food quality, service is very good and so clean .

Jordan Baszner

I remember these MASSIVE. pancakes as a kid every breakfast .

Star Longinotti

The hash brown casserole is out of this world. Everything on the buffet is yummy!!!

ALani Alamb

This place has my favorite salad bar ever!

Kim Mullins

The broasted chicken here is the best in town !

Michelle Webb

EVERYTHING is good here

DaveBeachy

Ask for sister Michelle Beachys section. Leave her a big tip. :)

Anne Shaw

Yummy bakery and more!

Beverly Moravsky

Buffet was great

Helen Stroup

Buffet is really great...

Trond Wuellner

Broasted chicken and pie !

Susan Pringle

The buffet is free for kids on Tuesday night! (rumor has it)

John Schoonejongen

The buffet is the best!!!!

Debra Press

The best chicken

John Schoonejongen

Buffet . Buffet . Buffet . 'Nough said...

Phil Stricker

The ice cream here is super rich and creamy.

SPENDY

If your under 65 dont go, your grandma makes better food, I gaurantee it!

Candria

I don’t know what’s going on at this place but the food and service is going downhill.

Kevin

Try the pumpkin bread . It's amazing!

Jon Cortes

Save room for Ice Cream !!!

Tonia Minor

Way over hyped! Nothing tasted fresh or homemade :(

Shannon Bowden

Buffet is way over priced at 12.99! It's delicious, but really expensive .

Donna Marie

I luv this place

Similar places nearby :

6.9
American
Steak 'n Shake

Fast service! Great food for the price. Can't beat it. - Melanie Champnoise

8.9
American
Cracker Barrel

Omg! First time at a Cracker Barrel and I'm hooked!! Great food! Ruben sandwich was amazing and the foil diner my cousin had was great too. Can't wait to try the breakfast food - Juan Hernandez

7.5
American
Stonewood Grill

Tilley is an awesome server. The steaks are delish. The orange cake is great for non dessert and dessert diners alike. - Valerie GG

7.2
Mall
Westfield Sarasota Square

Nice mall, clean, cool chairs, near satasotahookah.com - Sarasotahookah.com cprrecertify.com

9.0
Grocery Store
Trader Joe's

Best place for cereals and fruits and their shredded BBQ chicken is so good! - Holly Allen