Jack's Stir Brew Coffee

Premium quality coffee, friendly atmosphere, and great value – three tenets of service that Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee promises to deliver to their customers. This New York City coffee shop was founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola with one simple goal in mind: to deliver the highest quality coffee and ba...

8 / 10
266
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 267-5555

  • Website

    jacksstirbrew.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    jacksstirbrew

  • Facebook

    JacksStirBrewAmagansett

  • Type

    Coffee Shop

Address

146 Montauk Hwy Amagansett , NY 11930 United States

Credit Cards Yes
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Dessert

Comments / 63


Keywords:

coffee hampton pastries mad max sweet mary espresso drinks muffins desserts pressed juices scones casual good service ice cream breakfast sandwiches trendy comfortable seats people watching bagels good for a quick meal soup
christian svanes kolding

the queue may be long and some customers may very well be obnoxious but the coffee at this particular jack’s is consistently grand and i am forever enamored of the space’s northeasterly maritime vibe.

Tim Shey

I'm a little obsessed with the granola they sell here from local Anke's Fit Bakery - give it a try. And on second thought, since I don't get out there much anymore, can you bring me back a bag?

Mike Kallmeyer

Best coffee you'll find in Amagansett. Always busy, but worth the wait (especially when bumping into celebrities). Lots of artisanal snacks too.

Carmen da Silva

Open daily from 7-5 serving up one of the few organic , fairtrade, shadegrown cortado 's in town (oh and fresh pressed juices , homemade organic soups and vegan-ayruveda banana bread !) LOVE this place :)

Alex Bosworth

There are two separate coffee menus, look to the far right over the coffee machines for the other coffee menu

Dan E

Best cold brew , one size at this location. They also have breakfast sandwiches and Blue Marble ice cream

Christopher Sikora

A proper Espresso , traditional or iced, and a great spot to kick back on comfortable chairs and relax.

Megan

Much better ice coffee than Eli's (across the street), especially w almond milk . Jack's has almond milk ! Plus, the scones are super yummy!

Emily Wilson

Look out for a fancy vintage car out front... It might belong to Jerry Seinfeld.

Escape2NY Festival

We like the Dirty Harry & the Mad Max . Rumor has it Jack'll be programming the second stage at E2NY, aptly named "Jack's Stage" as well as serving his famous coffee ... stay tuned for more!

Raphael Langenscheidt

Crazy lines , great coffee . Use the express line to avoid the wait. Excellent vegan pastries !

Tom Wang

Everything here is good for your health. The compromise isn't always flavor friendly , but the food and coffee is excellent otherwise

Chet Mancini

Coastal vibe and best coffee in area. The specialty coffee menu is actually really good here.

Sam Pezzullo

They make a terrific latte . The cold pressed juices are also great, and so are the scones !

Barry Schuler

Best cold brew anywhere - and the mighty muffin will make you mighty.

EatMeDrinkMeNYC

The coffee alone makes this a great stop, but you'll find pressed juices , soups and oatmeal to make your stomach happy.

Matthias Schmitt

Accessible location in Amagansett. Very good coffee . You can sit out back in the wooden chairs or at the picnic tables . Doesn't have restrooms though.

Ashley Specht

Can't go wrong with the Sweet Mary . Perfect camomile tea for a rainy day.

Mike Fabbri

Really awesome coffee . Get the iced Stella! Skip the breakfast sandwiches though. Microwaved egg patty

Nikki Bogopolskaya

The iced coffee is like crack. Get an apple cider donut , you deserve it.

Rina

Serves the most perfectly soft, doughy donuts . Might be best I ever had.

Ryan Gallagher

I like this place but as soon as I walk in I feel like I am surrounded by assholes.

Tania

Great coffee and bagels

Tony Berkman

If you want, you can order the extra-big

John Duncan

Egg white and ham sammy on biscuit with an iced cappuchino

miles lennon

Expensive but good americanos

Mike Fabbri

My favorite coffee out east. Also, they have almond milk

Max Kostow

Affogato is one of the best ever. Get it.

Theresa G

great coffee - give the fit muffins and breads a try too

Marcie Quintana

I usually stick to a classic latte . 'Twas quite good.

Zack D

Best coffee shop in eh or mtk or world. Inside and outside. Its all good...

Chris Steele

Honey macchiato somewhat offset the deep off-season desperation behind the counter here.

Carolyn Chatham

Good coffee but slow since it is so popular and frequently has a line

Osh Stag Von Schlogan

Sweet Mary . Chai Latte made w Chamomile tea . Decaf and delicious.

erinocookies

If you're drinking coffee right now, get it here. It gets you going! They have soy and agave- great for iced coffee .

Lili Liaskas

Great coffee ... Try the Dirty Harry .

Wayne Bennett

Coffee decent, but not spectacular . Servers pour milk / cream for you, which I find annoying. Staff look burned out.

Ian W

Get the iced coffee just for the straw. Truly amazing straw

Ryan

Mad Max is always a good idea.

CC C

Repeat. Great Coffee to stay and great beans to go

Jeffrey W

Best coffee in the hamptons

Ollie Frank Scott

I really like this place

Jon Steinberg

Jack is super nice and a great enerrepreneur. Say hi

Outernational Inc.

Great coffee . But if you're in a hurry and the line is 5 people or more, skip it, they're slow. Read more

Frank Rimalovski

Cold brew !

Joe Brondo

Try a chocolate croissant - best in town , maybe the Hamptons !

Mark Weills

No tip other go here. Best coffee on the East End.

Bryce Pickering

Get the Little Zoe iced cocoa

jared zlotnick

Get the Mad Max and head to the back bench .

Fred Wilson

best iced cappucino

Similar places nearby :

8.2
Coffee Shop
Left Hand Coffee

Espressos, cappuccinos, lattes, cold drip coffee and new seasonal flavor lattes :) - Yannis Papagianni

7.4
Coffee Shop
Starbucks

Expert Vanilla Latté makers! Sweet enough without sugar. - JC Toledo

6.1
Coffee Shop
The Golden Pear Cafe

Turkey chili over rice is Delian. Best coffee in the Hamptons, too! - Bob Eck

9.1
Indian
Hampton Chutney Co.

The breakfast dosa is great and if you like cilantro the cilantro chutney is unreal. - Emily Wilson

8.7
Beach
Indian Wells Beach

Go for the Vanilla Ice Cream in a cone..... Delicious! - Bitsy Metcalf

8.9
Beach
Atlantic Avenue Beach

Great beach - busy on weekends but best beach food shack out east - love the fish tacos , beach burgers and kale salad ! - James Underberg