Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Rusty Bucket is a casual American restaurant and tavern, a gathering place where people come to share laughter, smiles, and great conversation over food that makes everyone happy. Satisfying and familiar, the menu is classic American fare, thoughtfully prepared from scratch by each location's Exe...

8 / 10
107
ratings
Address

1130 W 86th St (Ditch) Indianapolis , IN 46260 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards No
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 36


Keywords:

fried pickles good service sandwiches great value casual good for a quick meal root beer margaritas trendy meats brunch food restaurants dinner parking lunch town jalapeños cosmos habanero
Jennifer Doughty

I had the Philly cheesesteak and fries I added jalapeños this was amazing and the philly sauce was great and very different we also love the draft root beer !

Alaina Roberts

Great food! Try the Philly cheesesteak and sweet potato fries . They also keep house infused liquors - try the pepper vodka in a Bloody Mary

Rebecca Wilson

We went on a Sunday night and I got their hot brown. It was really yummy and the service was great!

Stephanie

The buffalo chicken sandwich with their homemade fries and fried pickles are thebomb.com!! The wait staff are amazing too!

Kelly Meyers

The grilled salmon salad is very good: strawberries , pecans I think, blue cheese dressing .

Marc Daly

We had good service . The waitress was nice, and the gentleman who brought our food was helpful.

David Harting

Very good food and very good service ! The fried pickles are yummy!

Dan Mulder

Pizza , fish tacos and Ribs were stellar

Macala Brown

Fried pickles and cosmos are the best :)

Dave Humphrey

The Fried Dill Pickles Chips are pretty good.

Tim Roe

Try the Habanero Wings !

Ryan Edmundson

Food and beer were great but the redneck next to me at the bar wasn't.

Greg Lambert

Strong drinks , good food, middle aged atmosphere

Evelina Edmundson

Tuna wrap is really good

Mike Abrams

Get a Lebatt Blue. It's one of the few places in Indy you can get one.

Lee Ann McKay

Try the snake bike . Guinness and ale . Yum.

Duane Stephen

Hot brown sandwich on Sunday

Denise Price Reidy

Nice, good music

Shaina Schwartz

Fried pickles were an awesome partner with my beer !

Tim Roe

Margaritas !

johny Lynch

Best sandwich in town ...

johny Lynch

Double nickle salad , and the buffalo sandwich !

Ashley Pifer

Try the fried pickles . Omg. Delicious

Blake Stephen

Hot Brown Sandwich .

Joseph Slacian

Try the meatloaf .

Kris Good

Great kay-so-dias

Mike Nelson

Excellent pizza .

Keith Yarbrough

Great fried pickles !!!

James Trèvis Boyd Jr.

Buffalo Chix Sand!!!!FANTASTIC!!

Andy Walsh

Here... its always a party!!

Aaron Spence

Best wings in town . Period.

Elise Lambert

86th Street inside the 21st Amendment and Flagstar Center

Matt Larrabee

Chili 3 way rocks

John Gerritsen

Guinness on tap !

Eric Wasson

Two words: Italian torpedo

Andrea Frew

Fried pickles

Similar places nearby :

7.5
Bar
Daddy Jack's Restaurant & Bar

It was great! Only place we could find in town that had Oysters on the half shell. And only$12.50 for six. Tilapia was amazing!! Great atmosphere too! - Jake Sims

7.9
Bar
Brother's Bar and Grill

The burger special on Tuesday was nice and cheap. The decor is very nice and rustic. Only visited once here - Glynn Geyer

8.1
Bar
George's Neighborhood Grill

Proportions are huge. With the fillet...perfectly medium rare...you are served soup of the day (mushroom was awesome), salad, starch (potato or rice), vegetable, and roll. Wine is $5 a glass. - Sanslenom

8.5
Pub
Taylor's Pub at Greenbriar

Live this place. Friendly bartenders. Good pours. Great food. Trivia nite is fun. - Marc Seleman

7.8
Pub
Taylor's Pub at Nora

The breaded tenderloin and fries are awesome here! - Shan Parker

Wine Store
21st Amendment

Biggest selection of liquor I've ever seen! - Jake Greenfield