La Piazza

The name you trust, the food you love. We are committed to bringing you the best Pizza in the area, and one of the best dining experiences you can have on Long Island. With locations in Plainview, Merrick and Melville. Call or come in today. No reservations required.

9 / 10
127
ratings
  • Phone

    (516) 938-0800

  • Website

    lapiazzaonline.com/plainview

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    111724938865366

  • Type

    Italian Restaurant

Address

1137 Old Country Rd Plainview , NY 11803 United States

Reservations No
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 38


Keywords:

pizza fantasia crispino great value good service salads casual eggplant good for a quick meal island dinner tomato sauce lunch sodas clean villas
Marco Vargas

My favorite spot! Hands down, great pizza . Born NYer and i have had tons of pizza in places all over NY and this is my favorite.

Jordan Rosenwein

Best buffalo chicken slice when it's fresh from the oven. They also have amazing real food like veal parm . Shrimp parm etc

Josh Rosenberg

Get the Fusilli Fantasia . It's not on the menu but they will make it for you if you order it. Pasta , sauce, chicken , onions , peppers and cheese . It is incredible.

David G

Try Cugini, 1/2 mile west, Bella Vista, 1/2 mile north, or Villa Monte 1 mi south in Tru Value Shopping Center. Just as good and genuinely appreciate your business.

Irene K

buffalo chicken slice , crispino , chicken ceasar salad and everythinggggg else!

Mo K

The grilled chicken tossed salad here is the best I've ever had!

Holly Shapiro

Best restaurant on long island - pecan salad , chicken primavera and fusili fantasia are some of my standard go-tos!!

Dustin

That buffalo chicken slice . I cross state lines for it.

Jason M.

Pricey but good, my favorite: buffalo chicken slice . Pretty excellent!

Ellen

Pecan salad with skirt steak is my go to meal here.

Rachel L

Great buffalo chicken slice

Mike H

Buffalo chicken slice is absurd. Possibly the best slice of pizza you will ever eat

Susan Perna

Everything

Amanda Silberman

Pecan Salad and Buff chicken slice ????????

IraFromSyosset

Eggplant Parma - Yummy! Some the best tomato sauce ever!

Faith

They have gluten free pies!!!!

Gary M

Pasta al cartoccio is fantastic

Jesse Ricciuti

Best buffalo chicken slice around.

Minju Lee

“Grandma” is the best

Stephanie Friday

Best Pizza Ive had in a long time!

Meaghan

Could b better Penne a la vodka is sub par bad portions not enough sauce or bread Awkward.... Pecan salad is a good choice,pizza ehhh ive had better for the price u pay NOT WORTH IT just for the price

Marino Mancuso

Great Meat-a-Balls!!

Brett Petersel

The best pizza on Long Island . Pasta-eria isn't bad, as well .

Matthew Pinkus

One of the best pizzas on long island

Larry Schena

Pizza is good.

Lisa Meller

The best chopped salad with grilled chicken

Joe C

Floppy slice of pizza and a cream soda ... Yeah buddy!

Noah Rosenthal

Crispino pizza . Period.

Gregory Scott

This Restaurant has no equal period

John Hitch

New chicken bacon ranch is rediculous

@irabrianmiller

Mmmm buffalo chicken - the best in the business

Brett Petersel

penne caprese: brilliant!

David G

Arrogant owners ( unless you're friends of theirs ). So many mediocre and/or bad experiences. Google their name to read about federal sex harassment case. Nasty people.

Marisa Rubin

I had the Eggplant Rollatini for a main dish!

Brett Petersel

If you want eggplant parmigiana , do this:Order the hero as it has the same amount of "filling" (meat, etc.) as the platter!

Marisa Rubin

For a side dish, I had the Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce for my cold!

Shawn Shifflett

Come with your full party. They don't seat partials, and the wait us too long as it is.

Andrew Avrick

A pitcher of soda is a bit much for two people

Similar places nearby :

7.8
Italian
Fanatico

Awesome chopped salad, especially the triangle bread it comes with - david weisfelner

8.7
Italian
Villa Monte

Delicious pizza! Try something other than a regular slice! - Mandi Gellis

6.2
Italian
La Piazzetta Cafe Pizzeria and Italian Restauraunt

You get ample size portion of food. Food is great and very classy place. - Nitroblast

7.2
Yogurt
Catch The Wave

Awesome, best frozen yogurt around. Nice local and friendly staff! - Cindy Licht

7.5
Pharmacy
Harmon

Rich is the nicest! Also great bargain bins and they have lots of products! - Andria McMaugh

6.1
Supermarket
ShopRite

Shopping here early is the best bet' and park on the side of the building or in the back of if you can, demolition derby at times ! - Gerard McNulty