Hartville Kitchen

You can't go wrong with anything on the menu! Fresh and delicious. Be prepared to wait in line .

Been eating here for over 25 years and never had a bad meal. The food is homemade and the service is always fast and friendly . People don't take day trips and stand in hour long lines to eat bad food.

The broast chicken is to die for. If you plan on going to the market or the hardware store next door eat last because you will never make it. Go during the week, they are closed Wednesday and Sunday .

Everything is comfort food at its best. Pie is to die for

Good food,nice service and never ran in to one bible thumper . Guess if your a Christian business you might run in to them here and their. Would be back

Awesome place! Fast service , great portions and everyone was friendly . No "bible thumpers " around... And I'm Jewish!

Amazing at the junk people sell there outside. We went on a Friday. Best day is Saturday or Minday

Great food and service. Pies are to die for. There are no bible thumpers here to bother you.

Go to Hartville Kitchen and order the Roast Beef dinner . Get the sweet potato casserole as a side - it's layered with brown sugar throughout. Vanilla Bean Pie and Peanut Butter Pie are MUSTS. Read more

Go for the creamed chicken with an order of sweet potato casserole . The bomb!

Highly Recommended. Roast beef , Mac & Cheese , Noodles , & Sweet Potato Casserole . Wheat buns and sweet tea .

Broasted chicken , noodles and all the pies !

Can't go wrong with the food

Food before visiting the bar .

Bible thumpers stalk the entrance handing out tracts. Run the Jesus Gauntlet for an amazing homestyle meal

Everything!

If frozen and canned food passes for an authentic homemade Amish meal then this place is for you.

Very good food and a candy shop!

Love the food!!

Carry out staff is Always accurate & friendly !

Very good food. Ignore the hippies previous comment.

Try the sweet potato casserole

This place is the shiz! Get the chopped sirloin

Roast Beef is the best!!

Roast beef and their sweet and sour dressing is the best

Best pies ever!!

Arrive an hour before you are hungry, that's usually how long the wait is.

Full of real Americans but not a bunch of "bible crap". Food is good and always consistent.

Be willing to stand in a long line !

Never leave here without dessert

the coconut cream pie is great

They r closed every wednesday and sunday