Pop's Seafood Shack & Grill

Pop's Seafood Shack & Grill is a bar Island Park located in United States.

8 / 10
195
ratings
  • Phone

    (516) 432-7677

  • Website

    popsseafoodshack.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    popsshack

  • Facebook

    140992139299173

  • Type

    Bar

Address

15 Railroad Pl Island Park , NY 11558 United States

Reservations Groups Only
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Music Live Music
Parking Street, Valet
Restroom Yes
Menus Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 65


Keywords:

summer spot in nassau county good for groups happy hour good for singles great value live music casual hole in the wall margaritas people watching tater tots dancing trendy grilled cheese sandwiches healthy salads beach egg rolls bar island good for special occasions
Erik Cintron

A great spot right off the water with sand and beach chairs come with family or a date. It has live bands , happy hour . The food is good and the staff is nice to look at. Come by car, boat or jet ski

Julia Tsyvin

Amazing hole in the wall where you can spend all day drinking and tanning on the beach and then eating amazing fresh seafood . Taylor the manager is a sweetheart. Great live band outdoors too!

Michael Balboa

Seafood platter and raw jumbo shrimp we're good..awesome atmosphere with amazing scenic water views #relaxing and nice #positivevibe

Natalie

Great time during happy hour and watching the sunset . I usually stay until about 10pm to have dinner and catch up with friends. Great view of long beach .

Valerie S

Fun summer spot, yummy drinks, and delicious seafood ! Try mussels , fish tacos , and lobster grilled cheese .

Amanda W

1) Grab a margarita at the back bar , 2) sit in a colorful beach chair , 3) stick your toes in the sand = recipe for the best Sunday Funday on Long Island .

Keith Lowis

Great place to eat, the food was absolutely delicious. Loved the fusion between Asian egg rolls & American hamburgers . The 2 1/2 lbs Muscle Paella was to die for.

Panagiota Pamela

best summer spot in nassau county-agreed. right by the water, have a frozen drink , stay late to hear beats

Glynis Rocks

Great for after beach day snacks and drinks... Mixed drinks are better when you sit at the bar and tip the bartenders

Jason Ian

Waited in line with a combo of young parents out for a good time and cheese ball kids borrowing their dads bmw's. I was so looking forward to this place. It took them 2.5 hours to bring our food!!!

Jacinta Ni Mhaithuna

Cool place but not too many options for vegetarians unless u want a salad ! If u have a burger and wraps selection, a veggie alternative would be nice!

Marisela Oquendo

Ridiculous that theirs valet at this place. Its casual ! No need for that! And a huge parking lot ! Let people park free! Ur food sucks BTW! Butttt great atmosphere!

Katie ???? California

My favorite bar and best summer hangout spot <3 I just wish most of the drinks weren't all $10 tho

Alana

Great disco band on Sundays. Band starts at 2pm. Very mixed age groups there.

Sheriann

They told us 2hr wait we went in anyway...went right to bar sat down ordered food...try the WARM Lobster Roll yummy!!!! Food is amazing

Tink P

Cool place! Old school jams ! Not many people here on a saturday night around the end of the summer which is good :)

Raied Farghaly

Good ambiance and fish and chips .

Journo Girl

Calamari is chewy. Corn on the cop is stale. Get seafood pot w/ linguine or fish & chips .

Amanda

Get the fra diablo mussels ! Soak up the sauce with bread afterwards.

Dan D

Get the red devil and you'll be dancing the electric boogie all night

Kev Skinny

Unique nightlife spot. A true long beach Bro play ground .

Marianne McKenna

Best burger in ages. Made to your liking.

Michelle DeMarco

Fish tacos are really good!! Erica is a great bartender .

Allison

If you can eat something that costs more than $20, you should be able to get wine in a glass...just sayin..

Sal Farieri

Absolutely the best summer spot in nassau county and quite possibly all of long island .

And-Gela Miller

Loved it can't wait to come back again????????????????

Allison

I used to say that they had the best lobster roll but I was disappointed. Lots of shells and nothing too exciting. Those tater tots , tho!

Tina DiS

The place itself is beautiful, the service is terrible. Waited 20 minutes for the bartender . I finally asked for my food order and she said "you should have told me earlier, the kitchen is too busy"

LaToya Darden

Had a great time....Pop's punch was yummy. Gonna try Ladies Night this Thursday

Jackie B

fun sand bar . get there early to snab seats by one of the firepits .

Will Scholl

Unnecessarily strict dress code for guys. It's a beach bar but I was turned away for wearing a tank top? Sucks when it's crowded but decent when it's slow.

Beth Schissler

Amazing seafood . Get the clam strips .

Ben Gasparini

Food is pretty good with large portions .

Deblette

somewhat fancy cool bar that gets you to talk on the sand.

Lauren Lavin

Horrible service. In the process of waiting for my drink -- it's been 10 minutes. This "guacamole " app is the saddest thing I've ever seen. So bland and flavorless, and 11 dollars! Pathetic.

Laurie D.

Great place for a crabcake and margarita !

Paige S

Definitely have the white sangria !!

Anthony Bulzomi

Great food and even better atmosphere. I def recommend!

Natalie Sylvestre

The food, PEOPLE AND WORKERS

Tracy Schmidt

Great atmosphere.

Didi Marie

Try a hot Lobster Roll for something different...

Caroline

Awesome atmosphere. Bring bug spray.

Andrea Martin

Tuesday night is great! Not crowded not too young

Dario Duplan

Valets are friendly :)

Helen Woods

First time there tonight but definitely not my last. Great people watching :)

Yan Kandkhorov

Love this place

Donald Carbonara

Definitely the best summer spot in nassau county

Sal Farieri

The hottest spot in Long Island , period.

Beth Schissler

Amazing clam strips

Peter DiSilvio

The food is good but the service is terrible. 40 minutes for a table even with a reservation , no napkins when they brought the food, and the waitress forgot three of our items.

Similar places nearby :

7.5
Bar
The Dark Horse Tavern

The Chicken wings are good. The place gets alive and packed during games. The back yard is a nice touch also. A must visit whenever I'm hanging out in the area. - Escape Cardona

7.2
Bar
Brews Brothers Grille

Wings & wing night, extensive beer list, games always on tv, excellent service and food that is much better than your average bar menu; def a great chef. - Chrissy D

7.9
Bar
The Wantagh Inn

I come probably 4 times a year..so I'm not a regular. But with that said I've always good service and most recently the bartender went out of his way to helo us. Treat them well and will reply in kind - Harry Vahjen

6.9
American
Minnesota's Grill & Bar

Sunday morning brunch, Crunchy Chicken Wrap (amazing),Blackjack on Saturday nights, Mussel Mondays - Mike Kujanek

8.9
Seafood
Jordan Lobster Farms

The Lobster Bisque and Tuna Salad are delish!! Friendly folks and great service! - Sammy V

7.6
Bar
The Inn

Friday’s in winter are but 1 get 1 entree, totally worth it. I got grilled salmon ????????friend had chicken parm? It was hugeeee - Karine S