Schafer's

Schafer's is a Port Jefferson landmark with breathtaking water views & elegant dining areas offering gourmet brunch, lunch & dinner options.

6 / 10
60
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 473-8300

  • Website

    schafersportjeff.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    schaferspj

  • Facebook

    Schaferspj

  • Type

    Seafood Restaurant

Address

111 W Broadway (Main Street) Port Jefferson , NY 11777 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Wheelchair Accessible Yes
Music Live Music
Parking Street, Public Lot, Private Lot
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 28


Keywords:

happy hour live music prix fixe menu good service filet mignon healthy food brunch food chicken bar dinner blue cheese lunch good for business meetings
Robert Piraino

The calamari is awesome and price is much more reasonable than the Steamroom. Only $10!! Bartenders on the roof are great, good service and live music on the weekends on the roof. Completely different

Stephen Juliano

If you're looking for quick, McDonalds is right next door. If you're looking for a great meal with time to spend with good friends, try Schaler's Pulled Pork Sliders and Blue Cheese Filet Mignon !

BIG D .

Crab cake app and chicken thomas dinner is amazing. Def try this tip! Go for a toasted lager too.

Christyn Malone

My husband and I stood at the rooftop bar for 10 min trying to get a drink and the bartender never looked over once!! Too busy talking to her friend. Bye bye!

Stephen Juliano

Sunday Brunch is awesome, and the unlimited Mimosas , Bloody-Mary's and champagne don't hurt either!

Michael Frost

Teach their staff that you don't book out an entire room for a private party during Sunday Brunch

Siobhan

Happy hour hummus is so good! Make sure you get your drinks from Rachel or Dan!

Caitlyn Deyak

Really good price fix menu ! And our waiter was really nice :)

Sarah Gladysz

Def. Party place! They never had good food :/ I went Fri. Night for bar club scene It was Awsome!!!! :))))

Explore Long Island

Our critic review Schafer's and loved the tasty fish tacos . Read more

Meghan Fleming

Be careful, Tommy's friends like to come up behind guys and choke them out for no reason lol

Sarah Gladysz

If u like to dance and party this is the place! Creepers and youngins stay out! Lol

Joe DLR

Truffle Parmesan fries were overly fried. Crab cake sandwich was filling yet nothing special. Slowwwwww waiters ... Mostly a retiree crowd today Sunday

Marie Goldstein

Drink as many mimosas as you want. They won't judge.

Renee Hendren

Sorry to say mc donald is now closed, i went to port jeff 7/10/2016 , billies is closed, and the village way closed . i ordered at steamrm, fish and chips , big fish , no taste, greasy

Brian Pinard

This place becomes a crazy club at night.

TC Didem Byrkglr

Brunch fresh salad immm

Jessica Joule

My friend is Spanish and had a white t shirt on and a kid comes

Kim Burke

The girl Taylor at the front desk is NOT nice

Will Maldonado

Bomb dj kid!!!

Kristin K

They stole my bar stool from me and made me stand! :(

jeff hoffman

Food blows calamari was the pitts never going back NEVER!!

Peter Schlussler

dont drink the becks for some reason its always bad:-)

Eric M

Food was ok, service sucked

Lauren Kolligs

It sucked.

Anil Ramchand

Slow service. Walked out after 20 mins of waiting to order.

Inara C

Terrible service on patio . They forgot everything.

Darren Cummings

Slow service, very rude staff .

Similar places nearby :

6.7
Seafood
Harbor Crab Company

The scallop crab meat mango special was delish. Prime rib wasn't that great tastes like typical wedding prime rib and not enough flavor. Mussels are amazing too. - Amanda Thalmann

7.3
Seafood
Land & Sea Fish Market

Gone twice. Thus far no complaints. I had lunch specials only. Fish sandwich, shrimp salad sandwich, the New England chowder, and seafood bisque. Love this local treasure. - Sandy Quesquen

7.7
Seafood
Oar Steak & Seafood Grill

Great food, friendly people. Can get very crowded. Try the seafood bisque. It has a little bite. If you're in for a little nosh, ask about the sandwich of the day. - Kristin C

6.6
Pub
Tommy's Place

Great food, great staff! Try the Ragin' Cajun burger! - Stephen Juliano

5.6
Pizza
Vincenzo's Pizzeria

Chicken bacon ranch is the best - ???? Jay P ®™

6.9
Bar
Portside Bar & Grill

8 dollar lunch special with fries,onion rings or salad and a free draft beer. Food was great. - Paul Inzerillo