Gaines Street Pies

Gaines Street Pies is a pizzeria Downtown Tallahassee Tallahassee located in United States.

9 / 10
79
ratings
  • Phone

    (850) 765-9275

  • Website

    gainesstreetpies.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    GainesStreetPies

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

603 W Gaines St, #3 (Between Macomb And Railroad) Tallahassee , FL 32304 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 19


Keywords:

pizza good service calzones great value cheesecake draft beer town comics parking lunch
Jonathan Webber

Great non-traditional pizza . Sauce has a unique taste. Is it cinnamon ? Salads and sandwiches good, too. A little pricey but worth it.

Arcade Age

Pesto chicken pizza was really good and had an excellent crust. Inventive menu and really cool comic-themed tables.

Madeline Smith

GSP is hands down the best in town . The Saucy Minx is the realness--super fresh ricotta and generous portions of meatballs galore!

Neichelle Loh

The White Album is the best white pizza I've ever tasted in my entire life – no exaggeration.

Anthony

X-men comics set out at the bar and amazing pizza . This place is perfect!

Ian Mott

Best pizza in town . Period. And everything else is on point as well .

Jamie Seidman

Whatever you do, you MUST try the cheesecake calzone . It's kind blowing.

Nathaniel Hall

The figure four is amazing plus Jai alai IPA on tap !

Ruby Rampage

Try the meatball sub , it's the best in town !

Rickey Helsel

Metal Mike, but you really can't go wrong here.

fresca

The jalapeño poppers are on point!

Samantha L

Lunch slices are a bit of a disappointment :/ toppings just thrown on top of a cheese slice

Jackie Jenkies

It's good try it out.

Nathan MacDonald

All the things are delicious.

Melissa Gilmore

Try a calzone . Yum!

Kenna Cottman

Garlic knots were on point

Jim Grantham

The animal is awesome.

Melissa Laird

Great food & service!

Marion Shaffer

Came to check it out it's alright but Decent Pizza is soo much better quality for the price

Similar places nearby :

7.9
Pizza
Uncle Maddio's Pizza

Great pizza! If you like your pizza with ranch, theirs is definitely worth a try! - Nicholas Hogue

7.2
Pizza
Midtown Pies

Candied jalapeños are delicious! - Kacie

7.2
Pizza
Decent Pizza

Good pizza and convenient location. Similar in style to another pizza place in TLH that shall remain nameless but without all try hubbub. Great for lunch. - Jonathan Webber

8.8
Lounge
Fermentation Lounge

Don't worry about bringing someone who doesn't like beer. They have a variety of ciders, wine, mead, and who knows what else. - Sarah Fowler

7.2
Coffee Shop
All Saints Cafe

The Toffee Nut/Hazelnut Italian Soy Cream Soda is amazing. - Desirée Amadeo

8.2
Art Gallery
First Friday at Railroad Square

First Friday at Railroad Square is fun and uniquely Tallahassee. Parking can be a hassle, but it's worth it. Bring cash with you. Venture in to the smaller galleries and stores, all friendly people. - Jonathan Webber