Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers has been serving up fresh, stone-baked pizzas to order in an eclectic, art-filled, and family-friendly environment. Each Mellow is locally owned and operated and provides a unique feel focused around great customer service and high-quality food...

9 / 10
100
ratings
Address

2340 E 116th St (Keystone Avenue) Carmel , IN 46032 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Beer, Cocktails

Comments / 30


Keywords:

pizza holly pretzels thai dye calzones good for groups casual mushroom soup spinach salad great value beer baked potatoes big portions bacon chicken dough meats lunch parking house specialties
Matt P

You can get a calzone like any of their specialty pizzas . Just be sure to ask for the matching sauce (BBQ for Funky-Q Chicken , Thai chili for Thai Dye , etc), cuz they all come w/ a side of marinara .

Natasha Shallon

Thai dye is to die for. All of the specialty pizzas we have tried have been hits. Also mushroom soup and pizza dough pretzels - yum!

Jenna Renee

You gotta try their potato pizza , it's like a perfectly baked potato with all the best toppings... But on their amazing pizza crust ! Just YUM!

Hub Miller

Been to many MM's. This is the best! Love the pizza , beers , and most importantly great service.

Christine Justice

Best calzone I've ever had. And it's vegan !

Carmel City Magazine

House Special Pizza made with spring water dough and topped with 13 ingredients including applewood smoked bacon

schalliol

Get the pretzels !

Heather Schmeltzer

Great gluten free pizza ! Highly recommend

Dan Finney

I always get the Kosmic Karma and add pepperoni . Fresh tomatoes + sun dried tomatoes + pesto = awesome!

Wade Stinson

They have good burgers ! The burner is soooooo good

Gina Mencias

They've gone full service. No more fill your own beverages. Enlightened Spinach Salad is yummy!

Ross MacIsaac

The pretzels and beer selection is great.

Belinda Lawson Miller

Funky Q Chicken Pizza & Pretzels are good????

Tricia

After 45 minutes of not even getting our pretzels and seeing everyone around us get served, we asked why and no one could tell us. Everyone at the counter just looked at us and shrugged. So we left.

Danny Oldham

Go to the bar and get holly as your server. Tip her well , she's the best!

Maria Carrillo

Ask for Owens as your server!! Wonderful.

Holly Hildebrand

Great pizza , great beer selection , and awesome service!! Ask for Holly :)

Sarah H

I would push someone's sweet grandmother out of the way for a slice of the Mad Italian, no joke.

Sara Moore

It was pretty good, service was a little off but good non the less.

Greg Golightly

Breadstick pretzels are great. So is pizza . A stella is a nice beer match too

Belinda Lawson Miller

Pizza is so good????

Sam Bothel

Never have had good anything here Pizza crap, Stromboli crap subs meh..salad had little to no greens

Emily Swangin

Best gluten free pizza place!

London Parker

Demand they bring back nacho cheese !!!!

Julia Stanich

Holly is the best manager :)

cory lynch

The house is awesome...like ten pounds of awesome

Seslie Smith

Have the calzone !

Jason Cash

The parmesan pretzels are the best

Mandi Huff

Gluten free pizza and beer !

Carmel City Magazine

Cory in the kitchen

Similar places nearby :

9.3
Pizza
Blaze Pizza

Build your own thin crust pizza. Ask for it crispy. Ready in minutes. Blood orange lemonade is great! - ᴡ Todd

7.7
Pizza
Puccini's Pizza Pasta

Campfire pizza is delicious. All pizzas are great. - Matt Icenogle

8.8
Pizza
Bazbeaux Pizza

By far the best pizza in town. We always order the house salad with creamy basil dressing. Our kids love the cheesy bread. Plenty of outdoor seating. One of the few restaurants that are worth the wait - Gina Hitzemann

7.2
Ice Cream
Baskin-Robbins

The Picnic Punch is a must try! Key lime pie is also pretty stellar :) - Katy DeWitt

9.1
Furniture and Home Store
World Market

I buy my whole bean Italian Roast coffee here. Great price for very good java. - Mark Thomas

7.0
Movie Theater
Regal Village Park

Small individual showing rooms. Popcorn is tasty and not too salty; rather tasty! - Mary Barbee