Millies Old World Meatballs And Pizza

Evoking memories of bountiful “Sunday Suppers” where families gathered around the table to share recipes passed down from generation to generation, Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza is bringing that same convivial feeling of a close knit Italian family to everyone.

8 / 10
123
ratings
  • Phone

    (973) 267-4992

  • Website

    milliesoldworld.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    milliesoldworld

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

60 South St Morristown , NJ 07960 United States

Reservations No
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 29


Keywords:

pizza meatballs good for dates lively good for groups BYOB spacious casual healthy food good for working turkey cheese dinner wood oven good for special occasions garlic lunch
Erika Arrea

Coal pizza vodka sauce meatballs to come back for!!! And fotmr the kids wood oven margarita fresh mozzarella perfect portion for 2

Cathy Mendez

Used to hostess here and am always coming back! Every choice of meatballs are amazing. You can't go wrong with any of the pizzas either, but I love the classic Wood Fired Margarita pie...to die for!

Lori Luo

Come for their signature meatballs , generously sized and served in a vodka or marinara sauce , as well as their wood-fired pizzas . The clam slice is a must-order.

John C

Extremely popular at moment and lines out the door because this is the only place in the area with coal and wood-fire pizza . Coal pizzas are large; wood pizzas are personal size. Excellent crust

Dede Willy

Its clean inside and lots of space but the meatballs which are the speciality are more dry and a good presentation all looks but closer to cardboard and tomato sauce was below par too acid pure Agita

Justine Burke

Meatball parm "app" is AMAZING. Vodka pie on the right side of the menu was to die for. Service was great too. Can't wait to go back!

Dede Willy

Attentive staff very clean kitchen, the tiny pizza was good but by no means great and overpriced for a plate sized pizza . How can you make a good pizza in 5 minutes? I mean It’s pizza not tapas

Kazem Edmond

Surprisingly good pizza . It's actually the best pizza I've had outside of NYC and, of course, Italy.

Frank

Plan on a noisy place that’s worth the inconvenience. Food is tasty. Meatballs are awesome (but not for the diet conscious)!

Michael Farano

Everything was Amazing. Owner gave us the personal treatment.

Rhea Burke

Food was delish! The ricotta crostini was a fave!

Lisa NYCnonprofit

3 meatballs w pasta and cheese for 15$. And 12 meatballs . in a pot

Chris Volinsky

Can get very crowded on weekend evenings-seems to be pretty hot right now. Pizza is good but kinda strange for a meatball place to have no pasta , right? Meatballs are fried so not exactly like moms.

Melanie George

We like the outdoor seating (not your typical metal chairs and table). Also a fan of wood-fired pizzas .

Chris Hermesmann

Food and service is excellent. Try the coal fired pizza . Really good.

Mike Cygan

Pepperoni and garlic wood fired pizza is fantastic, get it while it is available

Melissa Benzaleski

Meatballs were very good, but the pizza was to die for. ;) We were very pleased with the service as well .

Steve Kraynak Jr.

Meatballs with Vodka Sauce , Spicy Magherita Pizza and BYOB !

Firedrake Nemmy

OMG Those meatballs ... OMG that pizza ... Forget the shiny tributes, bring me more of those meatballs .

Duane Hand

Pot of Balls to go. Enjoy them at home!

Stephen Szabo

The meatballs and pizza are excellent.

Mikhail

Awesome meatballs with vodka sauce

Nathan Santomieri

The Millie's signature pie!!!

Scott Linde

was great actually very fresh

Cata Ramirez

The turkey meatballs are to die for!!! yumm

Duane Hand

Meatballs w/mozzarella and and wood fired pizza .

Dale

Meatballs are amazing!

Vincent Acquaviva

Order some meatballs !

Johnny Hackett

Pizza , Meatballs, Salad

Similar places nearby :

7.1
Pizza
Pomodoro

Best Italian Restaurant in Morristown by far. Pizza and dinners equally good. - Mark Davis

7.6
Pizza
Suvio's Pizza

Awesome pizza at a great value! - Shannon Sullivan

7.4
Pizza
Coniglio’s Old Fashioned

Pizza is really great. Expensive but very good. Nice fresh ingredients. - Lenny Gallo

9.2
Performing Arts
Mayo Performing Arts Center (MPAC)

Great facility comfy seats and not a bad seat in there. - Sandy Zweig-Miklush

7.7
Yogurt
Taro Frozen Yogurt

The Taro flavor is amazing. I also suggest the passion fruit boba topping - Jenn Stivers

8.5
Ice Cream
South Street Creamery

Everything here is awesome the milkshakes are my favorite there ice creams are very good they have coffee and even more good food like Paninis and much more stuff. - Will Ross