Carmella's an Italian Bistro

The linguine with mussels is insanely good. All the desserts . House chianti and Pinot noir . Literally: everything. Best Italian anywhere in the states . And it's in a strip mall ! Crazy good.

My absolute favorite Italian place within driving distance from my home. Great atmosphere inside and outside on patio . You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Have reservations .

Everything here is great! Pick something and enjoy! Don’t forget to save room for dessert as they are out of this world!

An amazing Italian meal ! Great service, wonderful atmosphere. A lovely patio -with a wait. A true Italian menu with a variety of selections. Not great for vegs - chick broth. A true gem in Apltn!

Best restaurant in the valley by far. Every bite of food was delicious and our server was incredible. Will be back in a heartbeat. Thanks for a wonderful meal and a great experience!

High quality Italian food . Outstanding three cheese soup with sweet sausage ; the lightly breaded veal in a white wine sauce and lemon over pasta was perfectly prepared.

City 's best Italian restaurant ,I ate a filet mignon with something like gnocchi baked with cherry tomatoes delicious that surprised me, even the lemonade is Italian.

Yum, yum, and YUM!!! This is a new favorite that we will visit every time we travel through Appleton! Fabulous salmon , beet salad , desserts !!!!

Best italian food in the Fox Valley! The staff here is awesome- too many to name, but make sure you say hi to the manager simon!

Outstanding! Don't let the strip-mall location turn you off. It is a gem. If you don't have reservations , be prepared to wait. Food is spectacular! Will definitely come back.

Everything is great and prepared really really nicely. It is definitely worth your money to eat here, even if it is a little expensive .

Everything is wonderful at this restaurant ! Save room for a fabulous desert too!

The Bucatini Bolognese is hearty and very good. I ate at the bar and they took very good care of me.

Voted best overall restaurant and best dessert in Post-Crescent Media's Best of the Valley! http://post.cr/BestOfTheValley

Amazing food and service on weekends get there early because its packed! Love it there great vibe!!

One of our favorites ....Hard to go wrong with anything on their menu!

Pappardelle was lip-smackingly delicious. It's a must try, guys. Give it a shot!!

The chili grilled shrimp is amazing. It's an appetizer but is perfect for lunch .

Awesome calamari ! The bread & oil is great as well .

Everything is made to order, fresh and local. One of the best restaurants in the valley

Be sure to get there early. Very early. The wait is completely worth it but can be very long.

Amazing waiters . Fuisi pasta is amazing! The dessert is delicious!

Best restaurant in Appleton. The veal is >>>

Love the food here! Some of the best in Appleton!

I recommend sitting at the bar the GM is a really good lady and has great recommendations

One of the best Italian eateries in the area...if not the best.

Excellent food and the service was top notch!

great food

Rigatoni with white wine ! Great combination :-)

Good food, big it was too dark. A little too much ambience.

The Ariana is fabulous! The alfredo sauce is also perfection.

The menu is in italian so good luck translating. Also the chicken pennini is awesome and delicious.

Reservations are highly recommended, but only available for a party of 6 or more.

Everything!

The patio in the summer is the place to be!

Everything is so delicious, very impressed! :)

Snobby waiter . I wanted to give by tip to the bus boy.Zuppe di pesce was mediocre. Special beet soup was good.

I'm a big fan of the fuscilli.

Loved the fusilli

Menu is easy to read cuz it's all in English. Not like Angelina's

The pasta fagioli is delicious!

The pappardelle is so delicious! Love this restaurant .

Fantastic.

Brandon is awesome. And try the arugula salad . It's delish!!

Menu is in Spanish which doesn't make any sense!!

Good grub good brew...

Copertino is wonderful, like smelling a bouquet of wildflowers !

Kallie is a great waitress here!!

The salmon is the best! Loved it!

The calamari is addicting.