Classic Slice

Great/large pizza by the slice. New York style thin crust . I love the Satyricon and cheesy bread sticks . Meatallica and Mediterranean also quite good.

After drinks at At Random, stop by neighborhood pizza joint Classic Slice, where you can grab yourself a piece of vegan pizza sprinkled with dairy-free cheese (plus any other toppings you desire).

Look at the size of that slice! It really was one of the best slices I've had. (I also lived in Italy for 3 years and at LOTS there).

The Italian beef sandwich is fantastic! It's hard to order pizza now that I've ordered this. It's like ordering ribs at Coerper's. It's what the cool kids are doing.

Hey #MKE #Vegans & #Vegetarians - The #Vegan homemade sausage ROCKS! Make sure to ask for extra #Soy #Cheese on #Pizza . The Vegan #Coconut & #PeanutButter #Cupcakes are INSANE - Enjoy!!!

The portions are monstrous, and it's wonderfully thin. They're very welcoming, and fun. The spinach and artichoke dip is divine

Great selection of toppings, more affordable for just a slice versus a whole pie . Nice size on the slices:-)

I have never seen such big slices, so be prepared. The pizza is delicious & so are the salads

Definitely try the (1) Mediterranean, (2) Pesto , and (3) Alfredo pizza slices. They're freakin delicious.

Huge slices, freshly made with incredible ingredients. Best pizza I've had in the United States .

Amazing pizza and they offer a great selection of vegetarian options , as well as wheat or gluten-free crust!

Even tho the food is good, the wait is unreal and .75 for each topping some may say is a bit steep-they shud offer topping slices instead

Massive slices of delicious pizza . Love the local sodas at the fountain .

Lots of great options, but don't pass up the lunch specials either!

Breadsticks with cheese , caprese salad , and pizza !!! Omg everything is good.

They make the most amazing gluten free banana cream pie ! Add some shredded coconut and you're golden.

Come with a empty stomach. The pizza is huge here! Greatest staff in any place in Milwaukee!

Great food! Mac n cheese . Balls n cheese pizza !

Can't go wrong with huge slices on thing crust with a ton of toppings at either the original or North Ave location.

Don't forget to add your own flavor with nutritional yeast , oregano , schiracha and more shakers!

They don't list their prices for speciality slices which I find highly annoying ???? guess they don't want you to know that you will pay at least $8-10 for just a slice-not cool

They use the Small Shop Member card. You can get one in the shop and then you register online. Read more

Pesto pie by far the best!

Can't beat the Pepperoni lunch special .

By far the best gluten free crust I have had!

Best pizza place in Milwaukee.

the occasional special slice of the week which we get as a pie, BBQ pulled pork is killer (via Scoville) Read more

It's not that busy but been waiting a while for jus a slice...hopefully they live up to their name

Avocado Salad was perfect

Big high quality slices.

Pineapple , anchovy , black olive , mushroom , spinach and onion pizza is AMAZING!!

Ridiculously amazing slices of pizza Prehistoric sized portions. Worth the drive and the wait. Yum!!

Any pizza gluten free . Awesome!

I recommend the pesto . my wife recommends the super veggie with vegan sausage . The calzone with cheese blend is also good.

Get the Meat-alica!! It's the BEST!!

Try the slice of the week. I just had the special with Italian beef , moz, and gardinaria. Pretty awesome. The crust was good too.

FYI that the Mac n cheese pizza still has red sauce on it (Ian's is boss) - get the Popeye instead!

Their canoli is the best!

Awesome pizza here. Try any, all, or some. You will love it!

Try the football sized calzone !

I like meat on my za, but I'll confess more than half of what I get here is vegetarian . (via Scoville) Read more

Italian beef.....Meatball...on Cibiatta...oh yeah

Best slice in MKE

Try the I'm feta up slice, it's delish!! Great pizza , great atmosphere, I love that they offer izze sodas !

Try the Popeye Pizza -

Meatallica !

Get a single slice of the day and a PBR Tall Boy here.

Be prepared to wait. It's worth it, but holy shit.

Try the Meatallica !

Some of the beat combinations in Milwaukee. If you aren't thinking pizza , then try the mammoth calzone !