Pick-A-Bagel

This is one of the best bagel shops in New York. Wonder why they have a low rating. Their bagels last a couple of days when bought fresh.

You can throw almost anything on your bagel . I like to go for a Salmon bagel with chives cream cheese and onions . Also check out their deals, soup & 1/2sandw for $6.25 or free soda with meat sandwich .

This location is far superior to the 2nd Ave one. Better, softer bagels and schmear, black and white cookies , and coffee . Staff is often harried but kind to regulars. Watch for crowds at shift change.

Everything! Try the everything bagel with lox , cream cheese and capers !! Can't go wrong no matter what you get though

My favorite bagel spot. Always fresh, excellent white fish salad & a generous schemer. Egg sandwiches are good too.

The bagels here are pretty good and the staff is friendly . I like the tofu spreads but sometimes they give me cream cheese by mistake.

I really want to like this place because the bagels are so good and the service is very nice, but they have messed up my egg sandwich 5 times in a row. I don’t understand, it’s such a simple order.

Good place. Owners super friendly nice ppl. I didn't even know they offer black/white cookies to my girls. Ty

My bagel with avocado and cream cheese was heavenly. The customer service was great also

Bagels are deadly good! Highest calorie bread you can eat - but OHH it feels good going down.

Good fresh bagels here. With a nice dollop of scallion cream cheese - YUMM!!

Came back ten minutes later. This time they corrected appropriate by giving 17.31 additionally back plus a few muffins free

They have the greatest sugar free muffins all flavors are great

Delicious bagels ! Fast service . Customer service could be better.

Good Black & White cookies . And a pretty decent cup of coffee .

Good food. Overcharged me by 20 dollars. Complained got 8 back. Store needs to higher ppl that do math. 3 pannini turkey club 4 drinks. 52 plus tax at most. Charged me 75.

Great food, great service! A little pricey , but it's NYC. Shop, Just above the 77th and Lex subway stop.

Expensive... But good quality foods and a wide variety of bagels ! Yum!

It is crazy to order a turkey bagel sandwich ! Just order a bagel and a quarter pound of turkey and you save three bucks.

Bagels are pretty reliable. Honestly though their prices are completely inflated a bagel and danish should not cost 10 dollars ????

Easily located right above the 77 Street 6 Train for commuters in a hurry

Egg salad bagel with lots of salt and pepper is delish

Tuna on a bagel with let tom onion nearly $9! Now I remember why i stopped going here a decade ago

Lox , cream cheese and the works is ON POINT

Be nice with the employees, because they are all supercute :D and make you delicious meals every time.

Love the everything bagel and lox cream cheese !

Try the shrimp salad w whole wheat everything bagel (lettuce &tom) you ll love it

Amazing bagels !

Addicted to the honey pecan cream cheese .

BLT but remind them to toast it!

The most legit black and (or) white cookies .

The egg salad is great, especially if you order it on a toasted whole wheat everything bagel .

A bit higher priced than the one on 23rd st

Muffins are soooo good.

Overpriced bagels . The guy handed me a 7 grain bagel with cream cheese . He tries to argue I ordered that. I said everything bagel . Who the fuck orders 7 grain bagels

know your order when you get to the counter.

It was the most expensive bagel i have ever eaten

The old guy will screw up your order every single time, and then make you feel guilty about it. Position yourself in line to avoid him.

These are not good bagels . Walk the few extra blocks to H&H.

Great coffee and bagels

Avoid the not-so-fresh fruit salad .

Open 24 hours now!

Always unfortunately disappoints. The bagels just aren't that good. If you have time, go to somewhat nearby Ess A Bagel . (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more

You need to have good food to be overpriced. This was OKAY, so super overpriced for what you're getting.

Banana Walnut muffin

man yelling about how he refuses to ever overpay for bagels

$8 for tuna on a bagel with nothing else on it. Has the world gone mad?

$14 for a soup and salad ...

Tasty vegan cream cheese .

Overpriced and terrible service. It takes too long to make anything on the grill or press. However food is good.