Caffe Amici

Get amazing deals at Caffe Amici. We've been providing delicious dishes. We offer a variety of affordable deals every day. Watch out for our promos! Located in Independence plaza in Selden, NY

8 / 10
102
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 698-0818

  • Website

    caffeamiciselden.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    154469214609514

  • Type

    Italian Restaurant

Address

353 Independence Plz (near Boyle Rd) Selden , NY 11784 United States

Reservations Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Drinks Full Bar

Comments / 29


Keywords:

Italian food marco polo good for dates good for groups good for a quick meal mousse meatballs bar garlic knots dinner panninis rice balls lunch gorgonzola cheese purses parking mozzarella crowded island
Benedict Joseph

Always check out the specials; an occasional surprise. Management and Staff are outstanding. I have been here a number of times with 2 people and up to 25. Good times, great food, and awesome service!

Joe Santoro

I had the ravioli Marco Polo last night ( pasta night mon & tues) it was one of the tastiest dishes I have had and I stole a meatball from my goddaughter that was delicious also .

Bill Porter

Don't listen to the bad talk the food is great and the service is excellent. Rachel is the best! Pasta Nights are packed to go early!

Frank Rivelli

We've been coming here for over 20 years, and we just loved it. However, last night we were very disappointed. They rushed us and dinner was burned.

James

One of the best Italian food on the island . Garlic knots are ridiculous.

Cat Rojas

Fantastic food! Angel primavera and the rainbow cookie mousse were to die for(:

Angela Katherine

Insalada amici with shredded mozzarella instead of gorgonzola is to DIE FOR!!

Stacey Katt

Food is good and the workers are really nice! Pasta night gets really crowded so go early.

John W

Great Meat Slice pizza and Rice Ball ..

Rahadyan Sastrowardoyo

I've had this place cater family events . Top notch food. Highly recommended.

Corey-Jason Saile

This place has been a mob front for years ... sup par pizza with extravagant decor. Pasta night isn't that bad but if you take your leftovers home they put it in a metal tin that taints the leftovers

Levorn O'neal

Great food for pasta night cheap and easy for a nice night out......^_^

Samantha Vogel

Pizza is very good

The Canz

Pasta Night is an amazing deal. Food is very good.

Michael Ripa

great food, great place!

Katie M.

Pasta purses are my favorite :)

Larisa P

Amazing pizza & pannini 's

Dawn Munchgesang

Awesome as always!!!

Meg

Bring a friend for his bday, they do one hell of a job singing but skip the Italian cheesecake , its not very good

Christina

Worlds best garlic knots !

Dave E

Stuffed pizza

Jennifer Fruecht????

Absolutely delish!!!

James Hackett

Good pizza but beware of the Jersey shore types behind the counter.

John Monderine

Julie hates the Sicilian slice

Mary Overeem-Melendez Minister

I get so sick the morning after never again

Ganimet Brija

Place is a ripoff on sundays 50 bucks for 2 pasta dinners n an apitizer and wasn't worth it at all

Josh Woolcott

Food was ok.......layout of the place sucked and there was no organization . Take out would be better!!!!

Ganimet Brija

Now I feel sick from eatig there fake shrimp absolutly gross will never waste my money again

Mary Overeem-Melendez Minister

????????????????????????????

Similar places nearby :

Italian
Villa Grazia

Chicken & sausage scarapiello (sp?) was insanely good! We devoured it! - Tina Bassett

6.0
Italian
Setauket Pastaria

The chicken fresh tomato fresh mozzarella and roasted pepper slice is very tasty! - Lisa Holmes Nasta

7.2
Italian
Olive Garden

Eggplant parm w/ whole wheat linguini was perfect. As was the salad starter. :) - Stephanie Varga

5.9
Hardware
The Home Depot

Nice Garden center, very organized & clean for a garden center - John W

7.1
Coffee Shop
Starbucks

Very friendly employees. Great place for grabbing a coffee at late hour. - Busra Yucel

7.3
Cosmetics
Bath & Body Works

Annual one day candle sale. Wow, what a line. Got the candles I was shopping for ???????? - John W