Made In New York Pizza

if you’ve experienced the prince st . spicy roni, give this one a try. similar and nearly identical pepperoni but needs a bit more sauce. overall solid.

A lot of hype with the press but it’s really amazing pizza ! Great sauce and big slices. Best in the UWS!

The spicy pepperoni is the slice to get here. Worth the trip if you’re not close by.

Recommend the sicilian style pizzas , they are the best. Pepperoni sicilian and vodka sicilian are the best

Sicilian spicy pepperoni is awesome.

A very good pizza . No frills but very tasty definitely recommended

not sure I’m a huge fan of these saucy pepperoni Square type pizzas . Sauce was really sweet

The Squares are all good the pepperoni is fantastic but the plain square may be better

The grandma slice and the mushroom slice great! Garlic knots are OK!

it’s not at the same level as Prince St ., but you’re getting more space to sit and have a beer in exchange

Had cheese and pepperoni when bradys parents were in town . Good!

Eggplant Sicilian slice

Solid New York pizza joint

Damn good slices

this is not good pizza , unfortunately

I don’t even know why Prince Street would sue this place, because they have nothing to worry about. The food here is awful! The crust is simultaneously raw and burnt, and the sauce is bad too.