Secret Sandwich Society

The McKinly, meatloaf sandwich , was great! Very filling, with 1000 island and crispy onions . Homemade ketchup for fries made it extra special. Sure beats plain old Heinz. The whole menu looked good.

I went on a Saturday afternoon...PACKED! Had the dynamo burger with fries ...fries were really good and the burger was juicy. Would definitely go back!

Really enjoyed the Jefferson and pimento cheese fries . Our whole group couldn't stop raving about their sandwiches - we will definitely be back.

The Jefferson sandwich was amazing. Beer menu is impressive. The bartender tonight was slammed but she worked her ass off with a smile on her face. Thx for the beer recommendation!

The Brussels sprouts are great! Love the Venus and they allow plant burger substitutes on the burgers ! Have always been satisfied with choices here! Also, servers have always been pleasant!

The Polk sandwich with pimento cheese fries was awesome! Their homemade ketchup is a little different but delicious.

Duchess cocktail ???? Eleanor salad ???? pimiento cheese fries ???? mushroom soup ???? and the kid loved her pb&j too.

hamburger and sandwich were great and the chips on the side. / Hamburger ve sandwich çok güzeldi eti, tadı ???? cipste ????

The food was great. The menu has a amazing variety without being overwhelming.

Big salads and sandwiches , perfect for a casual brunch .

The Lafayette was amazing, best fried chicken sandwich I've ever had!!

Pimento cheese fries ???????? and the Roosevelt with fried chips

Try the sandwiches !!!!

Everything, great selection.

With Two appetizers I can bring home leftovers in a box

Not so secret, watched it go from 2 tables to full with folks waiting for tables in less than 10 minutes at lunch time.

Everything

I have confirmed that the cat in the picture does not... I repeat NOT... reside at this restaurant .

Good sandwiches

This place is ok if need to eat something, and happen to be nearby and it is impossible to drive somewhere else.