Toby's Supper Club
Toby's Supper Club is a american restaurant Madison located in United States.
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd Madison , WI 53718 United States
| Reservations | No |
| Credit Cards | Yes |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
| TouchTunes Jukebox | Yes |
| Menus | Dinner, Happy Hour |
| Drinks | Full Bar, Cocktails |
Comments / 20
Keywords:
Get there early, especially on Fridays, order a set of drinks, as it gets packed at the bar really fast! Small establishment, but worth the wait---excellent fish fry and old-fashions! Highly Recommend
Best fish fry ! If you're going for the first time its a little overwhelming but don't get scared off! Find somebody who's been there before and ask them how it works. You definitely won't regret it!
Get the "real" fries - they're homemade . Pesto shrimp is amazing!
The bar staff makes great cocktails !
Friendly and comfortable .
Get an Old Fashioned and relax at the bar...drinks are super cheap .
Best fish fry in town ! Go with the perch !
Loved the brandy old fashion sweet!
Order quick, since they won't put you on the waiting list until you've got your order in
Friday cod fish fry w/hashbrowns and coleslaw=amazing. The baby pike was not good.
Order the shrimp ! You wont be disappointed!
Try the key lime pie margarita !
I'm sure the fish fry is great, but the hosting/seating situation is terrible! Who only has 2 people working the bar on Good Friday?
Great food, obnoxiously long wait time.
Yummy Long Island Ice Tea !
Pan Fried Chicken is great!
Cheese curds are not recommended.
Best Friday Night Fish Fry !
Best Old Fashions in the state
Unfortunately there is no singles night :(
Similar places nearby :
We had the cowboy burger and waffle nachos. Both were excellent. - Julie K
Mort's Pot Roast is awesome! Try the Curry and Coconut Mussels too! - Joshua B.
Plenty of good local beer on tap, and great burgers (beef, veggie, and salmon). - Adam Laiacano
Love the free soda, try the hamburger deluxe its awesome! - Angela Jones
Good food, nice folks and great food. Try the ground beef steak or chicken. Some of the best around! - Neal Richardson
Category Dining and Drinking » Restaurant » American Restaurant
Place United States » Wisconsin » Dane County » Madison