The Cottage

The Cottage on Siesta Key is a farm-to-fusion restaurant in a tropical setting that offers cuisine and libations inspired from around the world.

8 / 10
141
ratings
  • Phone

    (941) 312-9300

  • Website

    cottagesiestakey.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    150399008320874

  • Type

    Seafood Restaurant

Address

153 Avenida Messina (at Ocean Blvd.) Siesta Key , FL 34242 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Music Live Music
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 60


Keywords:

seafood happy hour margaritas tiradito live music rustic grouper sandwich great value good for dates good service key lime pie outdoor seating short ribs trendy bar tarts good for singles casual salads watermelon
Dan Schroerlucke

Amazing dining experience. Creative food-well executed, especially the kimchi mashed potatoes . Great atmosphere on the back patio . Highly recommended.

Farrah Shultz

Fantastic food! Mixed ceviche and crabcake were both absolutely fantastic. And great service!

☕Sarah????????

If you're ordering a beer , go with a bottle. Draft lines must not be cleaned often. Off flavors in my IPA .

Katie

By far one of the best meals I have ever had! The Cottage Cosmo was yummy, the parrot fish special was delicious and the key lime pie had the perfect amount of tartness .

Jasmine Moy

Short rib with kimchi , awesome. Great watermelon jalapeño marg . garden with live music as weather permits

Taryn A

Great happy hour from 12-7 on drinks and food, try the passionfruit mojito and shrimp egg rolls !

Katie Quilty

Adorable dinner place ! Try to get a table in the very back outside! Good Live music sat night too!

Theresa Fife Clark

Delicious modern fusian food. Somewhere we make a point to visit when we're in town .

Lauren Taylor

Good looking guys, awesome drinks and happy hour specials and amazing service. Will definitely be coming back!

Kenny Roberts

Lobster Bisque is phenomenal! Everything on this menu is amazing. You'd be crazy not to go here!

Michael Beattie

Amazing Cadillac Margaritas . Must try the Kimchi Mash & the Tuna Tacos !

Steve Hill

The tapas selection is phenomenal. Highly recommend the lobster bisque .

Mel L

the tiradito and pisco sours ...omg amazing. and this is coming from a legit Peruvian.

Nicole Laureen

The ambiance was nice as well as the service & the live musicians . However, the fare was a bit lacking in the flavor department & the portions were a bit small. I would probably go back for MOJITOS =)

Joanna Nasios

Meh - completely overpriced spot- food was just ok - nothing here was healthy on the affordable side - tacos pictured were mini (like2bites) for $13

Will Bean

First time having the grouper sandwich , Amazing!! Substitute the reg bun for the rosemary one... Love it!!!

Annie Alfstad

EVERYTHING is Delish. Must get kimchi ...

Our Man On The Ground

This hidden gem has a rustic down to earth seaside feel offering great fresh seafood . Happy hour 12noon to 7pm & live music . Read more

Jennifer Russo

Ceviche is delicious. Try the cottage sparkler if you like a fruity drink . Very loud bar , but a neigborhood "spot".

Viajandolavidaloca

Order the Tuna Tiradito with watermelon . So good.

Adam Bargar

Easy to miss backyard area, but be sure to sit out there for shade and live music .

William Winter

The Cottage has the best happy hour draft beer prices on Siesta Key. I've compared them all!

Jeremy Griffith

Dark n stormy is a great drink for a rainy night on the island

Carlos Porfirio

Amazing restaurant and ambient

Aru Karthikeyan

Crab cakes and Kimchi mash !! Loved these two ONLy.

Larry Debevec

Fun place, great servers and awesome food!!

Rebecca Plaine

Unique menu but the food was fantastic.

Lindsay LaVaque

Mahi sliders are the bomb!

ILYA SPEC

Ceviche is fantastic!

Will Bean

Dragonberry Mojitos are the best!!

Julie F

The ashi tuna was awesome!

Jin Tian

The burger is the best. Other stuff is over priced.

Jason Nealis

The jalapeño watermelon margarita is off the hook!

Rebecca

Theresa is a killer bartender . Loved the skinny margarita and the pisco sour .

Karen Magno

Chicjen sandwich with plantains yummy....

Richard Scire

Margaritas are awesome! They're made with fresh ingredients , not a mix! The stuff floating around in drink is not dirt.

Kevin Knecht

Incredible salmon and salad !!

Gschro

Great salad and fish slider !

Abigails Skincare

Best food on the island !! Great service. I  this place

Wendy Petrik-Carroll

Get the sushi !!!!!

Todd Woods

Great service, un-questionable food quality and choices!

Zach Wendel

Live music every night!

Paul Taylor

Great Happy Hour Menu from Noon to 7:00PM. $5.00 Mojitos !

Jonas Westin

The Cheviche is great

Jaime Gracia

Excellent ceviche

Shannon Reiter

Ahi with Watermelon - the bomb!

Amy Edgil

Just get the zen mojito

Rita Marley

Tricia is the best bar tender period (.)

Roger Hitchcock

Great skirt steak and music !

Harvey Shepard

Get the calamari !

Similar places nearby :

8.7
Seafood
Siesta Key Oyster Bar

Wonderful raw oysters at happy hour prices. Yummy buffalo shrimp as well. - Lezlie Whaley

7.7
Seafood
Lobster Pot Restaurant

Fiery Chicken Pasta was absolutely delicious for any non-seafood people out there! Excellent service, food, and atmosphere! - Brett

7.7
Seafood
The Old Salty Dog

The big fish sandwich and the fish stew are great! - Linda

7.3
Night Club
The Beach Club

Great live music choices. Ladies night gets packed here. It's one of the best places to hang out and dance in Sarasota. Don't get toasted and obnoxious, the bouncers will not hesitate to kick you out - Ariane H

7.0
American
Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village

Coconut shrimp to die for. Also liked the Sea Monster. - Jennifer Russo

8.8
Ice Cream
Big Olaf Creamery

Huge scoops, lots of choices, fudge and smoothies. Yum. - Robert A.