Brotherhood of Thieves is a pub Nantucket located in United States.
23 Broad St Nantucket , MA 02554 United States
| Reservations | No |
| Credit Cards | Yes |
| Wi-Fi | Yes |
| Outdoor Seating | Yes |
| Music | Live Music |
| Menus | Lunch, Dinner |
| Drinks | Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails |
The Brotherhood Of Thieves on Nantucket Has the Absolute Best Beer Cheese Soup in the World. It's worth a trip to Nantucket just for the soup .
The food is awesome. Can't go wrong with anything. Lobster BLT and pretzels are sooo good. Kat and Mike made are visit so worthwhile. They were so fun!!!!!
More hype than it was worth. With so many other incredible places to go during the summer, I wouldn't recommend here. Pros: they are open during the off-season and I hear the burgers are great.
Rosemary bloody mary was intriguing, I'm glad I tried it... but I'm still not sure if I'd order it again. My friends LOVED their purple limeade cocktails .
Named after the title of an 1844 pamphlet written on Nantucket by Stephen S. Foster, this bar and ordinary serves casual lunches and dinner , specializing in sandwiches and simple fare.
Their lobster bisque is incredible - big pieces of lobster and puff pastry baked on top.
You don't take American Express and you are in a TOURIST area? I am SO tired of cheap ass owners. It is the cost of doing business. Deal with it.
Come after 10pm for the hash fries - beer cheese and hash are the best on island !
Go with Hunter, he's the man. Also, best burgers on island & its Bill Bellichik approved
Not only are the burgers some of the best on the island , but their French Onion soup is outstanding !!
Love the clam chowder and the variety of burgers .
Scallops , beer , cider , salads , burgers
The soft pretzel rods are just doughy enough... Highly recommended! :)
Some of the best burgers you'll ever find on or off island !!!!
Banged my head on the rafters. Are some nachos . Jodi brought us lots of beers . #bestdayever
You're right about that. Best curly fries on the island ! Burgers are good too.
Eat in the basement . Or outside. But mostly the basement .
Nice place to get away from the crowds
Great German drafts
Chowder is awesome
Solid choice. Good food, great drinks, quality people.
Waited an hour to be seated in the cellar too close to other people. Drinks $12?
Good grog all year round
In the off-season, the $5 burgers are a great reason to come out of hibernation.
My favorite non-outdoors place on the island .
The service is great and the fried pickles are awesome!
Ahi Tuba sliders were EPIC!
Pay $35 to get on the mug club for life. $4 beer with your very own mug and a tshirt. Very exclusive. Good burgers .
Great bartenders
Chowder was awesome!
Favorite tavern on Nantucket!
best surf & turf i've ever had!
get the wings .
Awesome salad with seared tuna .
Best burgers on Nantucket, by a country mile
Good burgers , nice bar
Great burgers
The outdoor seating area has a dyson airblade in the bathroom..........clutch
French onion soup on a chilly day.
The Basil Haydens.
Best French Onion soup ever!
Don't take the burger ????
You'll need the sweet potato fries after beer #2
Don't have the shrimp tostadas . Not wonderful in any way. The beer tasting flight is good though.
Go upstairs at night, and treat Zack (the bartender ) well !
Not a good beer selection in the fall
Curly fries
Get the chowder
Really good lobster bisque !
Cheddar Cheese Soup : For the WIN! Read more
One of the more affordable places to grab lunch and cocktails in Nantucket. - Brittany Fisher
Specialty cocktails are good. The food is excellent. Had the pork short ribs with cracklings. Try the charred broccoli and the squid appetizers. - Jeffrey Wooten
Awesome spot. Great selection of beverage options. Awesome eats. Fantastic live music - Anna Petchell
In addition to their wide range of reading materials, BOOKWORKS also has an appealing selection of funky gifts, cards, beautiful stationery, unusual pens, fun toys, decorative ornaments - Jerry Daub