Gabby O'Hara's

Featured in the book COME HERE OFTEN?: 53 Writers Raise a Glass to Their Favorite Bar, edited by Sean Manning. Andrew W.K.'s favorite bar

7 / 10
155
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 278-8984

  • Website

    gabbyoharas.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    117228045021654

  • Type

    Pub

Address

123 W 39th St (btw 6th Ave and Broadway) New York , NY 10018 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi Free
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 41


Keywords:

great value happy hour shepherd's pie casual Reuben sandwiches staff authentic bacon well lunch dinner
Mandar M

Restrooms are downstairs - make a left at the end of the bar to take the stairs , don't walk to the end of the room :)

Compass

Cult-loved karaoke , whiskey cocktails make this pre-game and bar crawl favorite worth a solo stop in its own right.

E Millah

My favorite bar ... Ever. You can't get a tastier veggie burger makers combo and the staff are amazing. Tip well . The karma comes back.

Michael Constantine

For a Sunday night this place was pretty busy. Not elbow to elbow busy but busy enough to have good conversation over good drinks. Bartender Aiden was super kind as well .

Jay Sia

The bartenders are the real deal and are full of great stories. Great people, tip well .

Theresa Roldan

Dingy Irish pub with great jalapeño poppers but unsalted fries . It's a chill place

Erik Luebbe

They are open everyday till 4am. The kitchen is normally open till 1am. And all the bar tenders have sexy Irish accents haha

Tom M.

Great BLT with a ton of bacon

Daniel

Best laid back bar ever. Coolest staff and vibe. Veggie burger is the best ever!!!!

Kevin Chiu

Guinness was sour tasting here! Ruben and corned beef rubbery ????

TW ✈️????????

This is me & my sister’s meeting place on every NYC visit. ❤️

Fluying ✅

Great place for a late night dinner in midtown.

Aydın Çubukçu

You can't find a better pint of Guinness in NY... Good food and great people here.

eric bornemann

Standard issue midtown after work pub . Food is better than others. Place is no nonsense which works for me.

Robert Davoli

Great Guinness and Rubin

Barry Heard

Irish-accented and friendly bar staff .

Julia Moak

The crab cakes are straight up disgusting. Sticking with fish n chips or salad next time cuz I'll still be back!

Troy S

Reuben , beer , and great staff .

Chuck Weiss

The shepherds pie is really good, as are the kettle one martinis .

Ron Hsu

It's been smelling like fuel for the last few times I've been there with the delivery trucks idling outside all the time.

Chris Angelina

Lamb stew was off the hook!

Elissa Englund

Greatest (and best-looking) bartenders in NYC.

Eric Grant

A favorite hangout for the Razorfish crowd.

Myron Bradley

The prices are really reasonable for Manhattan .

Fluying ✅

Veggie burgers rock!

Brian

I book my hotels in NYC based on how close they are to Gabby O'Haras!

Marcos Bueno

sweet potato tater tots ftw

M L

Aidan is the best bartender ever!

Todd Patrick

Great Lunch Pub

Kristen B

Friendliest bartenders . Tip well !

Joe D

Approach the secret make out corner in the back with caution

Mairéad Ní Dhubhthaigh

Sound bartenders

Heidi C

Great staff , food is quite good as well .

Annie L.

Grapefruit & goose! Happy Bday Ren!

Tom Lambert

Beer is at a decent price but unfortunately the food leaves a lot to be desired. Ordered the french onion soup and it was so bad that it was the reason I left.

Aaron Whatton

Greatest bar & barteners......be sure to stop in.

Jared Brodsky

Don't order the wings . They come out with no sauce on them with a plastic cup of sauce on the side. Thumbs down.

Jess Friedman

Great bartender

Lev Gelfand

Good time. Not super packed.

matt preston

Buy Cathy and Mark a pint!

Lindsay Ackerman

Worst service ever

Similar places nearby :

6.9
Pub
The Copper Still

Love the Kentucky bourbon ale here. Draft $4 beers for happy hour until 7pm. nice and chill vibe here. I can even read a book and got a seat by the window. - Chaniya S

6.3
Pub
Amity Hall

Great afterwork spot. I like the sliders and skinny margarita! - Lovely G.

7.8
Pub
Lillie's Union Square

Great food, great atmosphere! Loved the mini Mac and Cheese and truffle fries!! Staff very friendly, a real gem of a place!! - M K

9.5
Park
Bryant Park

This place never fails to impress me. Probably my best park in the big apple. Yoga classes, live music, nice surroundings, books and great waffle place, could you ask for more? - Joury AlS

8.9
Basketball
Madison Square Garden

Cirque du Soleil was amazing! The theater is beautiful and you can see really well from every angle. The show was worth seeing and the Garden is very well kept. Great Theater experience at the MSG. - Bethel & City Tours

8.5
Plaza
Times Square

Everything is good here! I would recommend going in the evening because the scenery is beautiful. Even in the winter time here you can't go wrong. - Pamela Benford