Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Started in Chicago in 1977, it's as commonplace as Subway in some Northeastern cities . Try: “A Wreck,” made with roast beef , salami , turkey breast , ham and melted Swiss cheese ($5.80)

You can't go wrong with an Italian with hot peppers and a bag of chips . Their dream bars , sugar cookies , oatmeal choc chip cookies and shakes are on point. Welcome to NYC, Potbelly! #foodgasm

It's great for a cookie monster. Cookies in milkshake , free cookies with sandvich. Cookies on my tube.

Don't under estimate the turkey sandwich . Add their amazing hot peppers for a mild bite, lettuce, tomato and Pickle on the side. Toasted of course. Your taste buds wi thank you!

I have been waiting for this place to come to NYC!! Everything is amazing here and I love their mustard ! Not sure what they do differently to it but it's great.

Have you tried the secret menu ? Our concierge’s favorites: the Wrecking Ball (A Wreck + spiced meatballs ) and the Fireball (meatball sub topped w/ hot chili ). #delicious

Looove the Mediterranean sandwich with chicken ! Add mushrooms and it will be perfect!

Wreck with double meat and everything on it (mustard optional), any of the shakes , all of the cookies - only place I've seen that had oatmeal chocolate chip .

It's not on the menu , but you can order a "Wrecking Ball ". It's "The Wreck" + a meatball (costs a bit extra). Opt for double meat (+$1.80) for a 2nd meatball ! Tip from @Duchsauce .

Avoid coming here at lunch time. Line will be out the door. Come a little early or a little late. But if you choose to wait... It's worth it

Peanut butter milkshake . Best thing on earth. Don't look at the calorie count.

The roast beef is amazing! Get it with the hot peppers topping.

The Wreck with hot peppers is unbelievable. Add some BBQ chips and you're set.

Amazing. Just had my first Potbelly sandwich (the Wreck) and i'm addicted. So glad they're finally in NYC!

Free wi-fi and lots of seats after 2pm so you can eat and work on your laptop.

Everything. Is. Delicious.

Great sandwiches at reasonable price

THE WRECK with peppers and oil is a MUST!! I like to add lettuce, onion and mayo . #WINNING

Don't be intimidated by the line . They move fast. From outside the door in about 10 minutes.

Oatmeal chocolate chip cookie = retarded. You need to try it at least once. Nom nom nom

The wreck w/ everything is the best. Not as thick/heavy as you expect it to be!

One of the best Italian sandwiches and peanut butter chocolate shakes ever

Try the "Fireball". Meatball topped with their chili . Napkins are a must.

Turkey sando . Mustard , pickles , hot peppers , lettuce. Pickle on the side. Works like a charm.

This is my favorite sandwich shop ever. Get the wreck.

Pizza sub with all the veggies is excellent.

Can't go wrong with roast beef , mushrooms & Swiss! :-)

Get the wreck but ask for them to add marinara , delicious

Better then subway! Everything is fresh :)

this location offers Bigs. The Broad St location currently does not.

i was probably a little too excited to see a potbelly in new york. fingers crossed for jimmy johns soon! Read more

Free WiFi , live music , delicious sandwiches . Why aren't you here?

I love it here! Get their oreo shake ?

It's always freezing in here.

These subs are stupid cheap . Yum.

Ask fir the 'Hidden Station' on wheat

The cookies r really good :)

Try the meatball sub - it's fantastic!

fantastic sandwiches but 5:00 closing on saturday? seriously?

Jalapeños are a must !

First had this in DC. It is amazing.

Get the wreck with everything.

Cookies are the best!!

Try the Smoked Ham

Try the meatball sandwich

No more peanut butter milkshakes , despite offering PBJ sandwiches . LAME. ????????

Cookies are d

Want to manage expectation. Subway gives you more meat. Blah

Beats the hell out of the local Subway...

Slowest service ever and constantly mixing up orders