Gage & Tollner

Gage & Tollner is a steakhouse Downtown Brooklyn Brooklyn located in United States.

9 / 10
129
ratings
  • Phone

    (718) 875-5354

  • Website

    gageandtollner.com

  • Instagram

    gage.and.tollner

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Steakhouse

Address

372 Fulton St (at Jay St) Brooklyn , NY 11201 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 16


Keywords:

coconut layer cake steak cocktails hash Baked Alaska hen of the woods raw bar crowded dinner crispy food well
Crystal

Parker House rolls, crispy hen of the woods mushrooms , clams Kimsino, fried chicken , monkfish - all bomb

Benjamin Kintner

Everything is amazing, but the desserts are really spectacular. Save room! Service is off the charts good too.

Noah Weiss

Phenomenal. Perfect meal for two: clams kimcino , ribeye steak , “hash browns”, coconut layer cake , and a smattering of cocktails . Vibe teleports you too.

Jonathan R

Clams Kimcino , raw bar , and the steaks here are excellent!! Great cocktail program as well .

Kaitlin

Saw this place in a YouTube video and had to come after learning it’s one of the city ’s oldest steakhouses still in operation. It lives up to its legacy! Wonderful steak , service, and charm.

Omer Zach

If you don’t mind an intense garlickiness, the NY Strip is pretty amazing.

Kari Gåsemyr

Great place: historic interior and atmosphere, delicious food!

Kate

Delicious meal and fantastic service. Lucky was phenomenal!

Fernando Reveco

Steak , crab cake and cocktails

Rami Haykal-Manning

Get the crab soup , t bone and baked alaska

Jo

Baked Alaska

Lockhart Steele

Now this, this is a room.

Nicholas Bowers

The steak and the apps

I Amos

Cauliflower soup , coconut layer cake

Tudor Georgescu

egg nog sorbet

Camille Fournier

Baked Alaska , oysters

Similar places nearby :

8.8
Cocktail
The Sunken Harbor Club

Everything is amazing! There are probably 30 tiki drinks, and you really can't go wrong. Really great space and relaxed vibe. - Mikahla Vicino

8.6
Steakhouse
Gus's

Chicken liver and Lamb Loin are just amazing!! - Leon Bojalil

8.8
Steakhouse
Peter Luger Steak House

Such a great place ! The meat is incredible. Worth any penny. - Eyal Gantz

7.8
American
Patti Ann’s

Great shareable bites options and a nice, concise list of beers for easy drinking - Rick Nelson

8.2
Cocktail
Livingston Manor

This place is known for the cocktails but the food is awesome too. Great for sharing a few things. Get the kielbasa sandwich ???? - Gianna Nebbia

9.1
Seafood
Grand Army

The oysters are excellent, paired with a wide range of accoutrements served in droppers. Can't wait for oyster happy hour to start! - Ian Griggs

9.0
Bar
The Brooklyn Inn

i have no real useful tip other than go now and go often. lovely atmosphere, lovely guinness, lovely new favorite. - Madeleine Di Gangi