The Sweet Shop NYC

Retro Sweet Shop with vintage favorites, artisan chocolates and treats and the best ice cream in NYC.

8 / 10
151
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 960-8685

  • Website

    thesweetshopnyc.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    thesweetshopnyc

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Dessert Shop

Address

404 E 73rd St (at 1st Ave) New York , NY 10021 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Dessert

Comments / 34


Keywords:

ice cream oddfellows candy family-friendly gelato mud coffee casual cute cookies great value Thai tea banana pudding quiet marshmallows pies chocolate friendly staff salted caramel cornflakes sweet treats
Gentiana

Such an amazing place, had the hardest time deciding what to get there were so many options!! Decided to get the toasted marshmallow ice cream it was a unique amazing unforgettable flavor thatI loved!

Sleepy Browne

This has been my second time visiting the @ThesweetshopNyc and I love Salted Caramel but I had a sample of the fluffernutter and it is amazing.I ended up getting two scoops of the cherrymisu

eifeh

Cute little candy/desserts shop in the UES. Donuts are tasty. Nice selection of unique ice cream flavors . Try the buttermilk honey blueberry ice cream for something special.

Erica C

New favorite place! So cute and delicious, makes me nostalgic with the candy and good vibes. Get their homemade snickerdoodle cookies with ice cream inside! Best sweet treat 😍

Nina LoSchiavo

Easily one of the best store concepts on the Upper East Side and the staff is the greatest! Get the banana pudding , chocolate chunk , or Thai tea ice creams provided by Oddfellows .

Vivian Li

This charming place has il laboratorio del gelato , people's pops, oddfellows ice cream , and MUD coffee not to mention tons & tons of candy varieties (some hard to find)!

Steven D

Check out the ice cream , there's a reason people are standing outside in November enjoying it.

Nefertiti

Super friendly staff , really tasty doughnuts & ice cream , to-die-for milk chocolate butter crunch!

Jøsh Saitz

Kelly is the owner if this charming and unique candy and ice cream shop . They have a lot of hard to find candy bars .

John Shon

The guy gave us a ton of attitude and was throwing things around in the back. There are plenty of other ice cream shops in the area and this one is one I won't be going back to. #servicematters

Michael G.

Cornflake marshmallow cookie is delicious. Their ice cream is very good too

Russell Hirschorn

Huge candy selection , delish donuts and toffee . Will be back for some ice cream .

Gaetane Gomes

Cute shop with axing customer service, super friendly & knowledgeable staff , will definitely come back!

mspixi08

Great candy selection , and they even carry gelatin-free candies for those out there allergic like me...

Jason H.

Quirky owners to be sure....but the chocolate covered marshmallows are the best anywhere!

Ben Mackey

Ask for the ice cream menu. Don’t forget to add fudge and salt.

Nitzan B

Ice cream and tons of cool candies and sweets!

Lauren

Friendly staff and delicious donuts . A great addition to the neighborhood .

Yoni Zloczewski

You can mix and match ice creams from Oddfellows il Lab and van leeuwen - fat kid dreams come true

Kelly The Candyman

FREE MUD COFFEE with a purchase of a DoughLoco Doughnut ! Good the entire month of January !!! Just Show The Candyman or Pie Guy Your FOURSQUARE check in !!!

Ryan Gallagher

Great little candy shop. Has a lot of forgotten or foreign candy .

stephanie

free mud coffee when you buy a dough loco donut

Rachel Smith

Fun place lots of treat as fantastic mint gelato

Kelly The Candyman

Like us on Facebook and Twitter for social specials

Roseann LoSchiavo

All I can say is salted Carmel gelato a flavor explosion!

Chris Sansone

Ice cream in a Chinese food takeout box

Sleepy Browne

The butter pecan ice cream is a must.

Alyssa B.

Yummy cookies and cream!

Leanne Z

Have a little or a lot of everything.

Lina Lanovoi

Cotton candy ice ball! Yum

Wejdan ✨

Just go there! This place is insane!!!

Nicole Tseng

This place is heaven!!!

Justin Erenkrantz

5th Avenue bars !

R K

Eureka! Eureka!

Similar places nearby :

8.9
Desserts
Miss Madeleine

Awesome french boulangerie some of the best croissants in the whole of NYC - Paolo Barone

8.5
Desserts
Rice to Riches

Try the Understanding Vanilla - One of the best flavors to try in this spot - Built Frenchié

8.4
Desserts
Spot Dessert Bar

Try the Golden Toast - Best seasonal item on menu. Lighter than it seems. #dessert #icecream #toast - Nelson W

9.7
Park
Central Park

Great place to escape from the noise of the city. Huge area to explore with plenty of lakes and quiet spots to enjoy a picnic. - Carl Griffin

8.5
Bar
The Pony Bar

Great beers on tap, spacious and friendly staff. Chill spot for weeknight or Sunday beers. - Ranu Rajkarnikar

6.1
Pharmacy
Duane Reade

Impressive craft beer selection - rahul d