Emilio's

Our family has been bringing our pizzas, pastas, and the rich, authentic flavors of Italy to the people of Commack for 38 years!

8 / 10
123
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 462-6267

  • Website

    emilios-restaurant.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    emilioscommack

  • Facebook

    200889563285418

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

2201 Jericho Tpke Commack , NY 11725 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 41


Keywords:

pizza penne ala vodka good for dates good service lively great value good for a quick meal paninis cocktails salads homemade food mozzarella dinner parking meats Sicilian slices roasted peppers marinara basil lunch
CJ Gleeson

Whether your having a few slices (because you can't just have one) or having a dinner . You just can't go wrong with anything. Great place

Marco Navarra

Stopped in for a few quick slices...very friendly and tasty. Grandma's and marinara both very good! I'll come back and do the sit down restaurant based on this experience.

Gary M

Was there Fri night...very good Pasta Emilio...with shrimp ,sausage ,ham , over spagetti with a tasy cream sauce ..a glass of pinot grigio.and tartufo to close it out

Newsday

Emilo's three-layer Italian American lasagna features ground beef , mozzarella , a blend of regular and impastata ricotta , spices and fresh pasta . Read more

Brittany Zucconi

Nevermind. I got my drink. It's a delicious Italian beer high in alcohol . I'm just a snob.

Badyr Aschkar

The Pizza is the best !! The pasta dishes are awesome !!! Try the pasta Emilio!!

Daniel

Penne ala Vodka and Pasta Fagioli Soup were very very good

Mike Seilback

My favorite pizza place in the Commack area. Whether you have pizza , paninis , or entrees from the kitchen, its all delicious.

JoAnn Novello

Best pizza and Penne Ala Vodka , chicken parm

Brian Thomas

We visit this place when ever we visit home awesome everything

Tim Clarke

The gluten free pasta is actually really good!

Megan N.

Favorite Italian. Never had a bad meal here

Lena Q

Crispino: fresh tomato , mozzarella cheese , garlic , basil and red roasted pepper = awesome slice of pizza

Mike

Everything is good here

Yesi T.

Went here because I heard it was great. Wasn’t greeted. The person who took my order just took my CC never said have a good day neither thank u. The pizza was just ok and was pricey . Will not go back

Joe Norniella

Sicilian slice FTW

Tamara G

Everything Ive tried here so far is delish!!

Lena Q

Order a bar pie for take out . They're delicious and you can make your own.

Lena Q

Bar pies are really good too. You can make your own creation.

Jeff F

Extremely over expensive in the over expensive pizza place industry. Side of 2 meatballs was 8.95. Make your own judgement

Craig Agranoff

Probably the best pizza out of all this family places

Gary M

Try pasta Emilio...very good

Matt Restivo

sicilian is seriously life changing. worth the wait.

Holly Valinotti

The best Italian food on Long Island , hands down.

Ashley M

Grandpa slices . Best in the world

Megan N.

I cant come here without getting the gorgonzola salad !

Lauren D.

salad pizza !!

Neil Rodriguez

Great pizza

Meg

Best sicilian slice ever

Ken

Grandma slice ! You will not be disappointed.

Tzorj Xe

Grandma slice . The Best!!!

Jason Molinet

Crispo salad worth the trip.

Erin Grego

The California Salad is amazinggg!

Dan

The grandpa slices are phenomenal!!

Katrina Doell

Sicilian . #thatisall

Brittany Zucconi

Too many old people and just people in general. Not enough bartenders . There was ONE bartender . Needless to say I'm waiting here without a drink. Cool.

Jeff F

Extremely overpriced for what it is. No clue why so popular has to. Be location

craig lam

Get the Sicilian..the best you will ever have. I promise

Ryan Lombardo

Ask for the homemade whole-wheat rigatoni

Danny D

This place rocks!

Alicia F.

My advice is don't go here. Waiters are terrible the service is redic. Waste of two hours

Similar places nearby :

7.3
Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Pizza was great and service was just as good! Definitely coming back - Christan Leigh

7.2
Pizza
Taormina

The restaurant in back serves outstanding food with 5 star service. A hidden gem!! - Barry Roth

7.6
Pizza
Intermezzo Pizzeria & Restaurant

I am surprised this place isn't rated a 10. Their food is phenomenal, their prices are great and their service is fantastic. The chicken Capri with the side of penne pesto is unbeatable. - Brian Erickson

8.0
Desserts
Yogurt Crazy

We got lucky to found this while walking to the train station. Inside there is a big sitting area compared to other frozen yogurt outlets. Love here! - Victoria artis

6.1
Bowling Alley
Bowlero Commack

Food reasonably price. No pro shop. Awesome seating. - Sue Redding

6.3
Discount Store
Dollar Tree

Great place for college and party favor ideas. - Mary Palladino