Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Known for its high energy atmosphere and simple menu, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza uses 800-degree coal burning ovens to create a “well done” taste.

7 / 10
92
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 858-2625

  • Website

    anthonyscoalfiredpizza.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    anthonyscfpizza

  • Facebook

    anthonyscoalfiredpizza

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

6401 Jericho Tpke (the corner of Commack Road and Jericho Turnpike) Commack , NY 11725 United States

Reservations No
Outdoor Seating No
Drinks Full Bar

Comments / 20


Keywords:

pizza chicken wings good service onions fresh mozzarella parking alcohol dinner
Lonny Sherman

Chicken wings are awesome pizza is also good. The waitresses all have big boobs

Jeff F

Service great. Food decent. Sons fav place. Like the not so intense menu so ur not looking at it like sitting in a diner . A-

Tonya Asterame

Found two pieces of hair on my pizza ???? before noticing the hair however, the pizza was very thin and crunchy which is my favorite! Was pretty disappointed once I found the hair.

John Toomey

We could see people eating black burnt pizza as we entered. We were informed that is the only way it is served- we ran for the hills !!!

Christan Leigh

Pizza was great and service was just as good! Definitely coming back

William Zezelic

Meatball pizza was decent and wings were good. Great service. Pie in pj is better

Desireno Gause

Omg the caramelized onions on those wings are to die for

Maisha Hadley-Hodge

Burnt Fired Wings were not it! I read the reviews and decided to see what the hype was about. But the wings have no flavor or seasoning. Just a heavy charcoal after taste smothered in onions . No Bueno

Richard Schulman

Have to try the wings buried in sweet onions All baked !!!!

Kelly A

Oddly, this place is very, very loud . However, food was very good!!

Lyndah Ray

Try the fresh mozzarella philly cheese steak pie !!!

Tonya Asterame

Also felt very uncomfortable from the moment I walked in. Since it wasn't packed, the staff was just standing around staring at us. Plus there were very little options on the menu?! What's up w/ that?

Matt LoGuercio

Pot of meatballs , wings and pizza ! Boom-Game day meal!

Lyndah Ray

Bloody Mary

Brian Doxey

Great personal pies !

Ray Potenza

Great pizza pie’s

Lisa Gennari

the wings are amazinggg!!

Alexa D

40 minute wait for one pie for takeout is completely unacceptable. Do they use an easy bake oven?

Bonnie Realmuto

This place is so good best pizza

Jessica Sebastiano

This place has amazing food!

Similar places nearby :

8.5
Pizza
Emilio's

Whether your having a few slices (because you can't just have one) or having a dinner. You just can't go wrong with anything. Great place - CJ Gleeson

8.1
Pizza
Chefs of New York Pizzeria

Can't go wrong with any of their specialty pizzas and all of their food is amazing with nice portions at extremely reasonable prices. Favorite pizza place in the area for sure. - Kyle Ebinger

7.9
Pizza
California Pizza Kitchen

Chicken Chimichurri is delicious! Perfect if you want something light with a kick of spice. - Liz D.

7.3
Desserts
Chocolate Works

Everything it's chocolate! - Robert Pickwick

6.1
Supermarket
Stop & Shop

Obsessed with their brown rice vegetable sushi rolls! Always fresh, so I think! - Samantha Silverman

Trail
Hiking Path

Just enjoy the walk...as close to the water as you can... - John Helmus