Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper West Side

Our original Citarella gourmet market has stood on the same corner since 1912, with our own neighborhood following. Today, we’ve kept the friendly fishmongers and expanded the seafood counter to forty feet! Full-service butchers and chef-prepared foods await on the first floor...

9 / 10
143
ratings
Address

2135 Broadway (at W 75th St) New York , NY 10023 United States

Comments / 32


Keywords:

seafood gourmet shops coffee dark chocolate lemonade cake beef bread homemade food meats market House Blend charcuterie knowledgeable staff cheese fruit city apartments
Serious Eats

Believe it or not, upstairs at Citarella is great for rich chocolate and mocha-flavored cakes and fine cupcakes . It also has very good meat, and produce that is consistently better than Fairway's. Read more

BuzzFeed

Citarella is the place you’re guaranteed to find whatever high-end item you randomly find yourself needing, be it fresh truffles or a whole rabbit . Read more

Food Network

Bobby Flay visits Citarella Fine Foods, a gourmet market selling prime meats, fresh seafood and fresh pastas in New York, NY, on Food Network's FoodNation with Bobby Flay. Find more tips at FN Local. Read more

Brandon

Amazing fish selection and always fresh. Staff will always help you with cleaning or cutting if you don't feel like doing it at home.

Will Harahan

Love their prepared foods when they still have some remaining during the after work rush!

Caroline Schulweis

They have some of the best prepared food in the city .

Cristina R

I do most of my grocery shopping at Citarella. Prices are good, and the meat and fish are always fresh!!

DoubleDeuce

The prices on fresh fruits and vegetables are much better priced than you might expect. Definitely worth your time.

Citarella Citarella

https://m.facebook.com/?_rdr#!/citarella.foods?__user=100006907837144. If you really want to know where the food comes from and how dirty it is check out the link above.

Ben

Great upscale grocery store , good for prepared foods and salads

Maria Parfenova

Great gourmet shop ! Has high quality steaks and big lobsters !

Hauke Vagts

apart from outstanding seafood and beef they carry some nice dark chocolates !

Sara Y

Fresh fish is incredible. Ask for Steve at the counter, he's the best!

Eric Andersen

Don't forget about upstairs! Seems much quieter up here…

Joshua Newman

One of the best seafood markets in NYC.

Charles Guerrero

Great selection of prepared foods for any occasion.

Sandy Campbell

Generally the best fish in NYC. But I'm not impressed with their $14 a pound tuna salad . It's way too salty, too dry and doesn't have enough celery bits. Glad I only got 1/4 pound!

Linda Wang

Try their premade wraps ! I'm a big fan of their turkey and avocado wrap

Eliane vdB

This is my go to place for fish . The counter is great and the staff knowledgeable and helpful. The butcher counter is very nice too.

Leslie Greene

Amazing home made lemonade !

Julien Dassault

Great "épicerie fine" especially good for fish , bread , charcuterie and cheese .

Mark Lombardi

Good place to get quality meat and bread

Eric Andersen

Bellini in a can?

Tessa Clarke

Mini gourmet market !!

Alec Cohen

Fresh warm baguettes

Will Johnson

one of the best places in NYC to get seafood .

Bravo

Great seafood . -Carmen Gonzalez, Top Chef

Linda Alicea

Citarella's prepared foods are great. Had their new polenta and mushroom . Delicious!

Giovana Parasmo

Best bread in nyc!

patrick large

Fresh bread or rolls are the bomb, but go quickly!!

patrick large

House blend coffee is good and cheap !!

Door

Heerlijke dingen hebben ze hier.

Similar places nearby :

8.0
Grocery Store
Fairway Market

Has great freshly squeezed orange juice and really good fruit. It also has an amazing selection of cookies and foreign candy. - Georgina Jenkins

8.4
Grocery Store
Trader Joe's

Great healthy food with pleasing prices. Staff is there to help and there are always great tasters - Gia Lamothe

8.7
Grocery Store
Whole Foods Market

I love this store! They are really celebrating 4th of July with delicious swordfish nacho sampling. YUM! - Danielle s

9.0
Food & Beverage
Zabar's

Fresh and yummy bread! Ask them to slice it for you. We liked the Jewish rye. - Dom C

7.9
Wine Store
Beacon Wines & Spirits

Friendly and helpful staff, convenient location and hours, great selection. What more could one ask for? - Will Harahan

7.0
Coffee Shop
Starbucks

Clover brews are incredible. More flavors and aromas. - Michael Wilkinson