Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Swing by for some of the best pies in Chicago, including amazing seasonal creations , such as the mincemeat pie . They also take christmas orders from Dec 22nd through Dec. 24th! Read more

Forget cupcakes ! This place will change your mind about pies forever. Whether it's a chess, Elvis, or classic fruit pie you cannot go wrong. Throw away your birthday cakes and grab a pie instead!

Try seasonal creations (from strawberry-rhubarb in spring to apple and pumpkin in fall) and signatures (like the incomparable banana-cream) with a coffee . The pies are, in a word, extraordinary. Read more

The chocolate chess pie is quite great. They have a great selection of pies depending on the season. The blueberry pie is excellent as well .

Amazing pies , quiches and staff . You will not be disappointed with anything on the menu. As a southerner and a recovering fatty This place is so good and dangerous-I love it! The choc chess pie is #1

Great stuff. The s'mores pie is out of control.

Don’t miss the savory pies . A pork , apple and sage creation or classic chicken pot pie will provide much needed heartiness on chilly nights like these. Read more

Check the daily pie menu on their website! And go early! They run out quick. Got the coconut custard and chocolate cream, both soo good

Get the Fat Elvis Pie — graham cracker-peanut-pretzel crust filled with chocolate , peanut butter and bananas . Read more

Try seasonal creations (from strawberry-rhubarb in spring to apple and pumpkin in fall) and signatures (like the incomparable banana-cream) with a coffee . The pies are, in a word, extraordinary.

the chocolate chess pie is like a brownie in pie form. absolutely delicious!!

Pie that dreams are made of, seating, and great value to!

Even when chef Paula Haney was baking for some of Chicago's best restaurants , she always had pies on her mind. Last March, she finally opened her own place. Try the raspberry pie . Read more

The Apple Pie & The Rhubarb Pie are both delicious. Definitely returning.

WOW. Best pie I've ever had. Banana cream pie was life changing.

Former Trio pastry chef Paula Haney launched her bakery in 2009, but she still has a stand at the Green City Market , where she buys much of the produce for her stellar pies .

Get the passionfruit meringue or chocolate chess... or just get anything you want, it's all impressive!

Had the espresso cream pie and what a great surprise it was delightful!:-)

If you love pie , there is no better place in Chicago to indulge.

I'm a huge fan of the Chocolate Cream or Banana Cream pies . Recently tried the Orange Cream though, and I think it takes the cake ... er... pie . Read more

The Friendliest people work here and definitely try the rhubarb pie . In fact any pie the crust is killer.

Try the banana cream pie - just fantastic. The key lime pie was a bit too tart for my liking.

Paula Haney banana cream pie alone made her a farmers’-market celebrity, helping build the funds and confidence to launch a West Town pie shop in fall 2009. Read more

Try the chess pie , single pies and full size pies available

Fresh ingredients and nice warm pies . Super cozy !

Simply the tastiest. Selection of pies change daily

I'm a banana pie connoisseur, so as an expert I can safely attest this to be the best banana cream pie to grace this planet.

The best pies . Seriously. If you love pie , indulge here.

Tiny retro pie shop serves ginger cream, apple cranberry , Key lime , quiche , potpie, and scones with farm-fresh ingredients. Read more

If you could eat summer by the slice, it would taste just like the ruby-red strawberry rhubarb pie ($23) from Hoosier Mama. Read more

Everything is awesome.

Loved it, delicious pie and cocoa

OMG! It doesn't matter what you order...it's all scrumptious!

Excellent chicken pot pie and pumpkin pie

Lots of fresh baked pies . Love the banana

Best key lime pie next to Joes Stone Crab

The Chicago Sunrise is a real treat

Grab a small chicken pot pie for lunch on your way into work.

The Sugar Cream pie is to die for, and their rhubarb is also amazing!

It's nice that you can get miniature versions of a lot of the pies .

Paul Virant, chef of Perennial Virant, eats here on his nights off. He loves the Pie . Read more

Loved the pie !!

Apple, pear , cranberry pie - delish!

Skip the fancy packaging, string and business card...it will save all of us all a lot of time.

Do you have $7? Is it friday? Then why aren't you getting 3 slices of pie ?? (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more

WOW! Pies are unreal. They open @ 10am but sell out by noon. Nuff said Read more

Check out Hoosier Mama Pie Company as seen on Sugar High Read more

A neighborhood gem .

The Apple Pie !

Each of Hoosier Mama's five best-sellers is off the charts. Read more